观察干预:思考实验的逻辑
Observing Interventions: A logic for thinking about experiments
摘要:
这篇文章是从实验中学习逻辑的第一步。为此,我们调查的因果关系和(定性)认知推理的相互作用建模的正式框架。对于我们的方法来说,至关重要的是,干预的概念可以被用作(真实或假设的)实验的正式表达。在第一步中,我们扩展了著名的因果模型与一个简单的Hintikka式表示的认知状态的代理。在由此产生的设置中,人们不仅可以谈论代理关于变量值的知识以及干预措施如何影响它们,而且还可以谈论知识更新。由此产生的逻辑可以模拟思维实验的推理。然而,它无法解释从实验中学习,这显然是由它验证了干预措施的无学习原则这一事实所带来的。因此,在第二步中,我们实现了一个更复杂的知识概念,允许代理在进行实验时观察(测量)某些变量。这个扩展的系统确实允许从实验中学习。对于所有提出的逻辑系统,我们提供了一个健全的和完整的公理化。
英文摘要:
This paper makes a first step towards a logic of learning from experiments. For this, we investigate formal frameworks for modeling the interaction of causal and (qualitative) epistemic reasoning. Crucial for our approach is the idea that the notion of an intervention can be used as a formal expression of a (real or hypothetical) experiment. In a first step we extend the well-known causal models with a simple Hintikka-style representation of the epistemic state of an agent. In the resulting setting, one can talk not only about the knowledge of an agent about the values of variables and how interventions affect them, but also about knowledge update. The resulting logic can model reasoning about thought experiments. However, it is unable to account for learning from experiments, which is clearly brought out by the fact that it validates the no learning principle for interventions. Therefore, in a second step, we implement a more complex notion of knowledge that allows an agent to observe (measure) certain variables when an experiment is carried out. This extended system does allow for learning from experiments. For all the proposed logical systems, we provide a sound and complete axiomatization.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。