arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2110.14802cs.LGcs.GTmath.OCstat.MEstat.ML
收藏

你是自己论文的最佳审稿人:一种所有者辅助的评分机制

You Are the Best Reviewer of Your Own Papers: An Owner-Assisted Scoring Mechanism

University of Pennsylvania(宾夕法尼亚大学)

Weijie J. Su

摘要:

我考虑一个设置,其中评论者为几个项目提供非常嘈杂的分数,以选择高质量的项目(例如,大型会议论文集的同行评审),而这些项目的所有者知道真实的潜在分数,但宁愿不提供该信息。为了解决这种信息的保留,在本文中,我介绍了等渗机制,一个简单而有效的方法来提高不精确的原始分数,利用某些信息,业主是激励提供。除了评审员提供的原始分数之外,该机制还将所有者提供的项目从最好到最差的排名作为输入。它通过求解凸优化问题来报告项目的调整后分数。在一定的条件下,我表明,业主的最优策略是诚实地报告的真实排名的项目,她最好的知识,以最大限度地提高预期效用。此外,我证明了这种业主辅助机制提供的调整后分数比评审员提供的原始分数显着更准确。本文最后提出了等渗机制的几个扩展和一些改进的机制,以供实际考虑。

英文摘要:

I consider a setting where reviewers offer very noisy scores for several items for the selection of high-quality ones (e.g., peer review of large conference proceedings), whereas the owner of these items knows the true underlying scores but prefers not to provide this information. To address this withholding of information, in this paper, I introduce the Isotonic Mechanism, a simple and efficient approach to improving imprecise raw scores by leveraging certain information that the owner is incentivized to provide. This mechanism takes the ranking of the items from best to worst provided by the owner as input, in addition to the raw scores provided by the reviewers. It reports the adjusted scores for the items by solving a convex optimization problem. Under certain conditions, I show that the owner's optimal strategy is to honestly report the true ranking of the items to her best knowledge in order to maximize the expected utility. Moreover, I prove that the adjusted scores provided by this owner-assisted mechanism are significantly more accurate than the raw scores provided by the reviewers. This paper concludes with several extensions of the Isotonic Mechanism and some refinements of the mechanism for practical consideration.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑