arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2110.11468cs.CY
收藏

推荐还是不推荐?基于模型的项目匹配过程比较

To Recommend or Not? A Model-Based Comparison of Item-Matching Processes

Serina Chang, Johan Ugander

摘要:

推荐系统是现代在线平台的核心,但一个普遍的担忧是,它们可能会将社会拉向危险的方向(例如,朝向过滤气泡)。然而,衡量推荐系统效果的一个挑战是如何将这些系统下的用户结果与没有这些系统的可信反事实世界下的结果进行比较。我们采取基于模型的方法来应对这一挑战,引入了一个二分法的过程模型,我们可以比较:(1)“推荐”模型描述了一个通用的项目匹配过程下的个性化推荐系统和(2)“有机”模型描述了一个基线反事实,用户搜索项目没有任何系统的调解。我们的主要发现是,推荐和有机模型在个人和社会层面上产生了截然不同的结果,这得到了定理和真实数据模拟实验的支持。这两个过程模型在推理过程中也会引起不同的权衡,其中标准的性能改进技术(如正则化/收缩)具有不同的效果。正如预期的那样,收缩改善了两种设置中匹配的均方误差,但代价是在推荐模型中选择的项目不太多样化(不太激进),但在有机模型中选择的项目更多样化(更激进)。这些发现提供了一种形式语言,说明推荐系统如何从根本上改变我们搜索内容和与内容互动的方式。

英文摘要:

Recommender systems are central to modern online platforms, but a popular concern is that they may be pulling society in dangerous directions (e.g., towards filter bubbles). However, a challenge with measuring the effects of recommender systems is how to compare user outcomes under these systems to outcomes under a credible counterfactual world without such systems. We take a model-based approach to this challenge, introducing a dichotomy of process models that we can compare: (1) a "recommender" model describing a generic item-matching process under a personalized recommender system and (2) an "organic" model describing a baseline counterfactual where users search for items without the mediation of any system. Our key finding is that the recommender and organic models result in dramatically different outcomes at both the individual and societal level, as supported by theorems and simulation experiments with real data. The two process models also induce different trade-offs during inference, where standard performance-improving techniques such as regularization/shrinkage have divergent effects. Shrinkage improves the mean squared error of matches in both settings, as expected, but at the cost of less diverse (less radical) items chosen in the recommender model but more diverse (more radical) items chosen in the organic model. These findings provide a formal language for how recommender systems may be fundamentally altering how we search for and interact with content, in a world increasingly mediated by such systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑