回复关于“伽利略E26飞越木卫二期间高能质子耗竭所指示的活跃羽流喷发”的评论
Reply to comment on "An Active Plume Eruption on Europa During Galileo Flyby E26 as Indicated by Energetic Proton Depletions"
AI总结:
本文回复对Huybrighs等人2020年研究的评论,澄清一个羽流耗竭特征实为EPD粒子误标记伪影,但强调羽流可导致质子耗竭的结论仍成立,并论证不同能段损失并不矛盾。
摘要:
在Huybrighs等人(2020)的研究中,我们调查了伽利略号木卫二E26飞越期间的高能质子耗竭现象。基于粒子追踪分析,我们提出耗竭是由扰动的电磁场、大气电荷交换以及可能存在的羽流共同造成的。其中一个被识别为羽流特征信号的耗竭特征被证明是Jia等人(2021)所指出的伪影。尽管如此,我们在此强调,Huybrighs等人(2020)证明了羽流可以导致质子耗竭,并且这些特征应当被积极寻找。此外,关于扰动电磁场和大气电荷交换对耗竭重要性的结论不受影响。我们认为该伪影的成因是EPD将质子错误标记为更重的离子。该伪影使我们无法确认或排除是否存在与羽流相关的耗竭。我们还回应了关于MHD模拟的评论,并证明540-1040 keV的损失与115-244 keV的损失之间并不必然因羽流相关电荷交换而产生矛盾。
英文摘要:
In Huybrighs et al., 2020 we investigated energetic proton depletions along Galileo's Europa flyby E26. Based on a particle tracing analysis we proposed that depletions are caused by perturbed electrogmagnetic fields combined with atmospheric charge exchange and possible plumes. One depletion feature identified as a plume signature was shown to be an artefact Jia et al., 2021. Despite that, here we emphasize that Huybrighs et al., 2020 demonstrates that plumes can cause proton depletions and that these features should be sought after. Furthermore, the conclusions on the importance of perturbed electromagnetic fields and atmospheric charge exchange on the depletions are unaffected. We suggest that the artefact's cause is a mistagging of protons as heavier ions by EPD. The artefact prevents us from confirming or excluding that there is a plume associated depletion. We also address comments on the MHD simulations and demonstrate that 540-1040 keV losses are not necessarily inconsistent with 115-244 keV losses by plume associated charge exchange.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。