利用最优序分数搜索提高置换DAG搜索的精度
Improving Accuracy of Permutation DAG Search using Best Order Score Search
摘要:
稀疏排列(SP)算法是准确的,但在实践中仅限于约9个变量;贪婪稀疏排列(GSP)算法更快,但理论上不那么弱。可以给出一个折衷方案,即最佳顺序分数搜索,它可以提供与SP一样准确的结果,但适用于更大和更密集的图。BOSS(最佳顺序分数搜索)更准确,原因有二:(a)它假设了“brute faithfuness”假设,这比faithfulness弱,(b)它使用了与GSP使用的深度优先遍历不同的排列遍历,通过依次获取每个变量并将其移动到优化模型分数的排列中的位置来获得。结果比较BOSS的几个相关文件在文献中的性能,线性,高斯数据。在所有情况下,通过适当的参数设置,BOSS的准确性相对于竞争方法大大提高。在测试的配置中,具有60个变量的模型在合理的时间内对于平均度约为12的大样本是可行的,具有近乎完美的准确性,并且平均度为4的稀疏模型在笔记本电脑上对于约300个变量是可行的,同样具有近乎完美的准确性。还测试了混合连续离散和全离散数据集。混合数据分析显示,在较高深度,相同分数的情况下,BOSS优于GES的优势更加明显;离散数据分析显示,在相同分数的情况下,BOSS优于GES的优势非常小,可能不足以让人更喜欢它。
英文摘要:
The Sparsest Permutation (SP) algorithm is accurate but limited to about 9 variables in practice; the Greedy Sparest Permutation (GSP) algorithm is faster but less weak theoretically. A compromise can be given, the Best Order Score Search, which gives results as accurate as SP but for much larger and denser graphs. BOSS (Best Order Score Search) is more accurate for two reason: (a) It assumes the "brute faithfuness" assumption, which is weaker than faithfulness, and (b) it uses a different traversal of permutations than the depth first traversal used by GSP, obtained by taking each variable in turn and moving it to the position in the permutation that optimizes the model score. Results are given comparing BOSS to several related papers in the literature in terms of performance, for linear, Gaussian data. In all cases, with the proper parameter settings, accuracy of BOSS is lifted considerably with respect to competing approaches. In configurations tested, models with 60 variables are feasible with large samples out to about an average degree of 12 in reasonable time, with near-perfect accuracy, and sparse models with an average degree of 4 are feasible out to about 300 variables on a laptop, again with near-perfect accuracy. Mixed continuous discrete and all-discrete datasets were also tested. The mixed data analysis showed advantage for BOSS over GES more apparent at higher depths with the same score; the discrete data analysis showed a very small advantage for BOSS over GES with the same score, perhaps not enough to prefer it.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。