经济学家对气候变化损害的错误估计
Economists' erroneous estimates of damages from climate change
摘要:
经济学家预测,全球平均表面温度上升3 $^\circ$ C,全球变暖造成的损失将低至全球经济生产的2.1%,上升6 $^\circ$ C,则为7.9%。这些相对微不足道的经济损失估计-当这些经济学家假设人类经济生产力将比今天高出一个数量级时-与科学家预测的气候变化显着降低人类可居住性形成强烈对比。尽管如此,用于做出这种预测的经济和气候模型在国际气候变化辩论和政策处方中一直很有影响力。在这里,我们回顾了经济学家所做的实证工作,并表明它严重低估了气候变化的损害,犯了几个方法论错误,包括忽视临界点,并假设不受天气影响的经济部门与气候变化绝缘。最根本的是,有影响力的综合评估模型DICE被证明是无法产生经济崩溃,无论损害的程度。考虑到这些缺陷,经济学家对全球变暖经济损失的经验估计应该被视为不科学而被拒绝,并且已经校准的模型,如DICE,不应该被用于评估气候变化的经济风险,或用于制定减轻损失的政策。
英文摘要:
Economists have predicted that damages from global warming will be as low as 2.1% of global economic production for a 3$^\circ$C rise in global average surface temperature, and 7.9% for a 6$^\circ$C rise. Such relatively trivial estimates of economic damages -- when these economists otherwise assume that human economic productivity will be an order of magnitude higher than today -- contrast strongly with predictions made by scientists of significantly reduced human habitability from climate change. Nonetheless, the coupled economic and climate models used to make such predictions have been influential in the international climate change debate and policy prescriptions. Here we review the empirical work done by economists and show that it severely underestimates damages from climate change by committing several methodological errors, including neglecting tipping points, and assuming that economic sectors not exposed to the weather are insulated from climate change. Most fundamentally, the influential Integrated Assessment Model DICE is shown to be incapable of generating an economic collapse, regardless of the level of damages. Given these flaws, economists' empirical estimates of economic damages from global warming should be rejected as unscientific, and models that have been calibrated to them, such as DICE, should not be used to evaluate economic risks from climate change, or in the development of policy to attenuate damages.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。