逃离阿罗定理:优势-标准模型
Escaping Arrow's Theorem: The Advantage-Standard Model
AI总结:
本文提出优势-标准(AS)模型,通过同时弱化阿罗定理中的IIA和严格社会偏好关系的负传递性,证明可以逃离阿罗式不可能性定理,且多个有吸引力的集体选择规则(包括传递性规则)均满足AS可表示性。
摘要:
社会选择理论中有大量文献研究弱化阿罗不可能性定理假设的后果。这些文献大多表明,在保持序数偏好设定的情况下,除非严重违反无关备选独立性(IIA),否则无法逃离阿罗式不可能性定理。本文提出一种更为积极的展望。我们提出一个用于比较选举中候选人的模型,称之为优势-标准(AS)模型。集体选择规则(CCR)可由AS模型表示这一要求抓住了IIA的关键洞见,但弱于IIA;同时又强于文献中所谓的弱IIA(在$x,y$上相同的两个偏好剖面不能在$x$和$y$上具有相反的严格社会偏好)。除了为违反IIA提供动机之外,AS模型还使另一个阿罗式假设的违反变得可理解:严格社会偏好关系$P$的负传递性。以往文献表明,仅将IIA弱化为弱IIA,或仅将$P$的负传递性弱化为无环性,仍然会导致不可能性定理;而我们证明,同时将IIA弱化为AS可表示性并将$P$的负传递性弱化,则不会导致此类不可能性定理。事实上,我们证明若干有吸引力的CCR是AS可表示的,甚至包括传递性的CCR。
英文摘要:
There is an extensive literature in social choice theory studying the consequences of weakening the assumptions of Arrow's Impossibility Theorem. Much of this literature suggests that there is no escape from Arrow-style impossibility theorems, while remaining in an ordinal preference setting, unless one drastically violates the Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives (IIA). In this paper, we present a more positive outlook. We propose a model of comparing candidates in elections, which we call the Advantage-Standard (AS) model. The requirement that a collective choice rule (CCR) be representable by the AS model captures a key insight of IIA but is weaker than IIA; yet it is stronger than what is known in the literature as weak IIA (two profiles alike on $x,y$ cannot have opposite strict social preferences on $x$ and $y$). In addition to motivating violations of IIA, the AS model makes intelligible violations of another Arrovian assumption: the negative transitivity of the strict social preference relation $P$. While previous literature shows that only weakening IIA to weak IIA or only weakening negative transitivity of $P$ to acyclicity still leads to impossibility theorems, we show that jointly weakening IIA to AS representability and weakening negative transitivity of $P$ leads to no such impossibility theorems. Indeed, we show that several appealing CCRs are AS representable, including even transitive CCRs.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。