arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2107.14013cs.HCcs.CY
收藏

解释性思维:理解和解释行政司法补救途径的可视化

Explanatory Journeys: Visualising to Understand and Explain Administrative Justice Paths of Redress

Jonathan C. Roberts, Peter Butcher, Ann Sherlock, Sarah Nason

摘要:

行政正义关注的是个人与国家之间的关系。它包括对儿童教育、社会照顾、许可证发放、规划、环境、住房和无家可归等决定的补救和申诉。然而,如果有人有投诉或问题,人们很难理解不同的可能补救途径,并探索适合他们情况的途径。解释性可视化有可能以清晰的方式显示这些补救途径,使人们能够看到,理解和探索他们的选择。可视化的挑战更加复杂,因为信息分散在许多文件、法律、指导和政策中,需要司法解释。因此,没有一个单一的补救途径数据库。在这项工作中,我们提出了我们如何共同设计了一个系统,以可视化的行政司法途径的补救。同时,我们对专家研讨会、启发式评估和专家批判性反思的基础数据进行了分类、整理和组织。我们有四个贡献:(i)解释性可视化工具(Artemus)的应用设计研究;(ii)整合数据的协调和共同设计方法;(iii)住房和教育方面的两个深入案例研究,展示了行政法中的解释性补救途径;(iv)对专家共同设计过程和专家数据收集以及行政司法和法律解释性可视化的思考。

英文摘要:

Administrative justice concerns the relationships between individuals and the state. It includes redress and complaints on decisions of a child's education, social care, licensing, planning, environment, housing and homelessness. However, if someone has a complaint or an issue, it is challenging for people to understand different possible redress paths and explore what path is suitable for their situation. Explanatory visualisation has the potential to display these paths of redress in a clear way, such that people can see, understand and explore their options. The visualisation challenge is further complicated because information is spread across many documents, laws, guidance and policies and requires judicial interpretation. Consequently, there is not a single database of paths of redress. In this work we present how we have co-designed a system to visualise administrative justice paths of redress. Simultaneously, we classify, collate and organise the underpinning data, from expert workshops, heuristic evaluation and expert critical reflection. We make four contributions: (i) an application design study of the explanatory visualisation tool (Artemus), (ii) coordinated and co-design approach to aggregating the data, (iii) two in-depth case studies in housing and education demonstrating explanatory paths of redress in administrative law, and (iv) reflections on the expert co-design process and expert data gathering and explanatory visualisation for administrative justice and law.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑