基于滑动时窗贝叶斯分析的模型结构误差诊断
Diagnosis of model-structural errors with a sliding time-window Bayesian analysis
摘要:
确定性水文模型的不确定性,但推断是时不变的参数通常表现出时间依赖性的模型结构误差。如果一个水文过程在自然界的某些时间段内是活跃的,但模型没有解决,就会出现这种错误。这种缺失的过程在校准过程中可以作为模型参数的时间依赖性最佳拟合值而变得可见。我们提出了一个正式的时间窗口贝叶斯分析来诊断这种类型的模型错误,正式的问题\In的校准时间序列的模型在统计上不合格本身为准真?“使用贝叶斯模型证据(BME)作为模型性能指标,我们确定校准时间序列的时间窗口中的数据支持或反驳模型的程度。然后,我们跟踪BME滑动时间窗口,以获得一个动态的,时间窗BME(tBME)和搜索突然下降,表明发病的模型误差。tBME还允许我们针对数据对模型执行正式的滑动似然比检验。我们所提出的方法旨在检测错误发生在不同的时间尺度上,这是特别有用的水文建模。我们说明了这一点,我们提出的方法应用到土壤水分建模。我们在几个合成和现实世界的测试案例中测试tBME作为模型误差指标,我们设计这些测试案例以改变误差源和误差时间尺度。结果证明了该框架在动态模型中检测结构错误的实用性。此外,后验参数分布的时间序列有助于研究模型误差的原因,并为模型的改进提供指导。
英文摘要:
Deterministic hydrological models with uncertain, but inferred-to-be-time-invariant parameters typically show time-dependent model structural errors. Such errors can occur if a hydrological process is active in certain time periods in nature, but is not resolved by the model. Such missing processes could become visible during calibration as time-dependent best-fit values of model parameters. We propose a formal time-windowed Bayesian analysis to diagnose this type of model error, formalizing the question \In which period of the calibration time-series does the model statistically disqualify itself as quasi-true?" Using Bayesian model evidence (BME) as model performance metric, we determine how much the data in time windows of the calibration time-series support or refute the model. Then, we track BME over sliding time windows to obtain a dynamic, time-windowed BME (tBME) and search for sudden decreases that indicate an onset of model error. tBME also allows us to perform a formal, sliding likelihood-ratio test of the model against the data. Our proposed approach is designed to detect error occurrence on various temporal scales, which is especially useful in hydrological modelling. We illustrate this by applying our proposed method to soil moisture modeling. We test tBME as model error indicator on several synthetic and real-world test cases that we designed to vary in error sources and error time scales. Results prove the usefulness of the framework for detecting structural errors in dynamic models. Moreover, the time sequence of posterior parameter distributions helps to investigate the reasons for model error and provide guidance for model improvement.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。