网上购物的黑暗模式:关于狡猾的伎俩,感知的烦恼和各自的品牌信任
Dark Patterns in Online Shopping: Of Sneaky Tricks, Perceived Annoyance and Respective Brand Trust
摘要:
暗模式利用界面元素来欺骗用户执行不必要的操作。在线购物网站经常采用这些操纵机制,以增加他们的潜在客户群,促进他们的销售,或优化他们的广告工作。虽然暗模式通常是成功的,但它们明显抑制了积极的用户体验。特别是,对于客户的感知烦恼和信任投入到一个给定的品牌,他们可能会有负面影响。为了研究深色图案的使用、用户感知的烦恼水平和他们表达的品牌信任之间的关系,我们进行了一项基于实验的调查。我们实现了一个虚拟的在线商店的两个版本,即一个使用了五种不同类型的暗模式,另一个没有这种操纵性的用户界面元素。然后,将总共$n=204$参与者转送到两家商店之一(约$2/3$到使用深色图案的商店),并要求购买特定的产品。随后,我们测量了参与者的感知烦恼水平,他们表达的品牌信任和他们对技术的亲和力。结果显示,那些使用深色图案版本的在线商店的人的感知烦恼水平更高。此外,我们发现感知烦恼和参与者表达的品牌信任之间存在显着联系。然而,我们的数据并不支持参与者对技术的亲和力与他们识别并因此对抗黑暗模式的能力之间的联系。
英文摘要:
Dark patterns utilize interface elements to trick users into performing unwanted actions. Online shopping websites often employ these manipulative mechanisms so as to increase their potential customer base, to boost their sales, or to optimize their advertising efforts. Although dark patterns are often successful, they clearly inhibit positive user experiences. Particularly, with respect to customers' perceived annoyance and trust put into a given brand, they may have negative effects. To investigate respective connections between the use of dark patterns, users' perceived level of annoyance and their expressed brand trust, we conducted an experiment-based survey. We implemented two versions of a fictitious online shop; i.e. one which used five different types of dark patterns and a similar one without such manipulative user interface elements. A total of $n=204$ participants were then forwarded to one of the two shops (approx. $2/3$ to the shop which used the dark patterns) and asked to buy a specific product. Subsequently, we measured participants' perceived annoyance level, their expressed brand trust and their affinity for technology. Results show a higher level of perceived annoyance with those who used the dark pattern version of the online shop. Also, we found a significant connection between perceived annoyance and participants' expressed brand trust. A connection between participants' affinity for technology and their ability to recognize and consequently counter dark patterns, however, is not supported by our data.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。