模拟数据与经验数据典型相关分析与偏最小二乘法比较
Comparison of Canonical Correlation and Partial Least Squares analyses of simulated and empirical data
摘要:
在本文中,我们比较了一般形式的CCA和PLS的三个模拟和两个经验数据集,都有大的样本量。我们从这些数据中连续取较小的子样本,以评估灵敏度、可靠性和再现性。在块内或块间无相关性的空数据中,两种方法在样本量上的假阳性率相等。两种方法在数据中也显示出等效的检测,具有弱但可靠的影响,直到样本量降至n=50以下。在强效应的情况下,两种方法表现出相似的性能,除非一个数据块内的项目的相关性很高。对于PLS,除最小样本量外,强效应的所有样本量结果均可重现。相反,CCA的重复性下降时,块内相关性高。如果进行主成分分析(PCA)并使用成分分数计算交叉块矩阵,则可以改善这种情况。我们的研究结果提供了三个信息。首先,对于块内和块间结构合理的数据,CCA和PLS给出了可比的结果。其次,如果在任一块内存在高相关性,则这可能损害CCA结果的可靠性。CCA的这个已知问题可以在交叉块计算之前用PCA来补救。然而,这假设PCA结构对于给定样本是稳定的。第三,原假设检验不能保证结果是可重复的,即使是大样本量。这一最终结果表明,对任何数据都要评估统计学显著性和再现性。
英文摘要:
In this paper, we compared the general forms of CCA and PLS on three simulated and two empirical datasets, all having large sample sizes. We took successively smaller subsamples of these data to evaluate sensitivity, reliability, and reproducibility. In null data having no correlation within or between blocks, both methods showed equivalent false positive rates across sample sizes. Both methods also showed equivalent detection in data with weak but reliable effects until sample sizes drop below n=50. In the case of strong effects, both methods showed similar performance unless the correlations of items within one data block were high. For PLS, the results were reproducible across sample sizes for strong effects, except at the smallest sample sizes. On the contrary, the reproducibility for CCA declined when the within-block correlations were high. This was ameliorated if a principal components analysis (PCA) was performed and the component scores used to calculate the cross-block matrix. The outcome of our examination gives three messages. First, for data with reasonable within and between block structure, CCA and PLS give comparable results. Second, if there are high correlations within either block, this can compromise the reliability of CCA results. This known issue of CCA can be remedied with PCA before cross-block calculation. This, however, assumes that the PCA structure is stable for a given sample. Third, null hypothesis testing does not guarantee that the results are reproducible, even with large sample sizes. This final outcome suggests that both statistical significance and reproducibility be assessed for any data.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。