arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2107.06476cs.DLcs.SIphysics.soc-ph
收藏

科学技术中的适应性与转型惩罚

Adaptability and the Pivot Penalty in Science and Technology

Ryan Hill, Yian Yin, Carolyn Stein, Xizhao Wang, Dashun Wang, Benjamin F. Jones

AI总结:

本文提出一个量化研究者偏离现有研究程度的框架,通过分析数百万篇文献和专利发现普遍存在且日益严重的“转型惩罚”,揭示了适应新机遇和威胁面临的巨大挑战。

摘要:

科学家和发明家在不断演变的问题、机遇与挑战的格局中设定其工作方向。本文引入了一个测量框架,用于量化研究者在产出新成果时偏离其现有研究的程度。我们将该框架应用于数百万篇科学出版物和专利,揭示了一个普遍存在的“转型惩罚”,即研究者越偏离其先前工作,新研究的影响力就越急剧下降。转型惩罚在科学出版和专利申请中几乎普遍适用,且在过去五十年中其幅度不断增长。尽管创造力框架建议研究者进行探索性搜索会带来益处,并经常强调局外人在推动突破方面的优势,但我们几乎没有发现这种优势的证据。转型惩罚与研究者日益狭窄的专业化相一致,当研究者进行大幅转型时,其工作的一个特征是与既有先验知识组合的互动较弱。研究格局的意外冲击可能会将研究者推离现有领域或拉入新领域,这进一步证明了实质性的转型惩罚。COVID-19提供了一个大规模的案例研究,许多研究者参与了该疫情研究,但转型惩罚依然严重。转型惩罚在不同领域、职业阶段、生产力、合作和资金环境中均成立,突显了适应性挑战的广度和深度。总体而言,研究结果表明,在适应新机遇和威胁方面面临着巨大且不断增长的挑战。研究结果对个体研究者、研究机构、科学政策以及科学和整个社会应对突发需求的能力具有启示意义。

英文摘要:

Scientists and inventors set the direction of their work amidst an evolving landscape of questions, opportunities, and challenges. This paper introduces a measurement framework to quantify how far researchers move from their existing research when producing new works. We apply this framework to millions of scientific publications and patents and uncover a pervasive "pivot penalty", where the impact of new research steeply declines the further a researcher moves from their prior work. The pivot penalty applies nearly universally across scientific publishing and patenting and has been growing in magnitude over the past five decades. While creativity frameworks suggest a benefit to exploratory search by researchers and often emphasize outsider advantages in driving breakthroughs, we find little evidence for such an advantage. The pivot penalty is consistent with increasingly narrow specializations of researchers, and when researchers undertake large pivots, a signature of their work is weak engagement with established mixtures of prior knowledge. Unexpected shocks to the research landscape, which may push researchers away from existing areas or pull them into new ones, further demonstrate substantial pivot penalties. COVID-19 provides a high-scale case study, where many researchers engaged the pandemic, yet the pivot penalty remains severe. The pivot penalty generalizes across fields, career stage, productivity, collaboration, and funding contexts, highlighting both the breadth and depth of the adaptive challenge. Overall, the findings point to large and increasing challenges in adapting to new opportunities and threats. The results have implications for individual researchers, research organizations, science policy, and the capacity of science and society as a whole to confront emergent demands.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑