arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2107.06215math.OC
收藏

从成对获胜指数得分

Scoring from Pairwise Winning Indices

Sally Giuseppe Arcidiacono, Salvatore Corrente, Salvatore Greco

摘要:

在随机多准则可接受性分析中计算的成对获胜指数给出了一个备选方案优于另一个备选方案的概率,该概率考虑了与决策者在参考备选方案的成对偏好比较方面提供的信息兼容的假设偏好模型的所有实例。在本文中,我们提出了一种新的评分方法,分配一个值,以总结结果的成对获胜指数的每一个选择。在文献中已经提供了几种程序,根据成对获胜指数为每个备选方案分配得分。然而,虽然他们都计算这个分数只是为了排名的替代品考虑,我们的方法,表达分数的附加值函数,允许分解的整体评价的贡献考虑标准的总和中的每个替代品。这样不仅可以对备选方案进行排序,而且还可以解释一个备选方案获得评价的原因,从而填补某一排序位置。为了证明该方法在代表决策者的偏好方面的效率,我们进行了大量的模拟,改变了替代方案和标准的数量。从统计的角度分析的模拟结果,显示了我们的程序的优点。通过一个与财政资金评估有关的案例研究,说明了该方法对决策问题的适用性。

英文摘要:

The pairwise winning indices, computed in the Stochastic Multicriteria Acceptability Analysis, give the probability with which an alternative is preferred to another taking into account all the instances of the assumed preference model compatible with the information provided by the Decision Maker in terms of pairwise preference comparisons of reference alternatives. In this paper we present a new scoring method assigning a value to each alternative summarizing the results of the pairwise winning indices. Several procedures assigning a score to each alternative on the basis of the pairwise winning indices have been provided in literature. However, while all of them compute this score just to rank the alternatives under consideration, our method, expressing the score in terms of an additive value function, permits to disaggregate the overall evaluation of each alternative in the sum of contributions of considered criteria. This will permit not only to rank the alternatives but also to explain the reasons for which an alternative obtains its evaluation and, consequently, fills a certain ranking position. To prove the efficiency of the method in representing the preferences of the Decision Maker, we performed an extensive set of simulations varying the number of alternatives and criteria. The results of the simulations, analyzed from a statistical point of view, show the goodness of our procedure. The applicability of the method to decision making problems is explained by means of a case study related to the evaluation of financial funds.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑