实验者的困境:对总体的推理偏好
The Experimenters' Dilemma: Inferential Preferences over Populations
摘要:
我们比较了经济学家和其他社会科学家在实验中常用的三个人群:在物理位置(实验室)的本科生,亚马逊的土耳其机器人(MTurk)和多产的。比较是沿着三个维度:由于疏忽,每次观察的成本,和响应的弹性的数据中的噪声。我们从每个群体中抽取样本,研究四个一次性游戏中的决策,其中个人和社会有效选择之间存在不同的紧张关系。当没有紧张时,个人和亲社会的激励措施相吻合,嘈杂的行为占MTurk观察结果的60%,多产的19%,实验室的14%。考虑到成本,如果噪音数据是唯一的关注点,那么从推理能力的角度来看,多产占主导地位,将相对较低的噪音与实验室五分之一的每次观察成本相结合。然而,由于实验室人群对治疗更敏感,在我们的主要PD游戏比较中,实验室仍然优于Prolific和MTurk。
英文摘要:
We compare three populations commonly used in experiments by economists and other social scientists: undergraduate students at a physical location (lab), Amazon's Mechanical Turk (MTurk), and Prolific. The comparison is made along three dimensions: the noise in the data due to inattention, the cost per observation, and the elasticity of response. We draw samples from each population, examining decisions in four one-shot games with varying tensions between the individual and socially efficient choices. When there is no tension, where individual and pro-social incentives coincide, noisy behavior accounts for 60% of the observations on MTurk, 19% on Prolific, and 14% for the lab. Taking costs into account, if noisy data is the only concern Prolific dominates from an inferential power point of view, combining relatively low noise with a cost per observation one fifth of the lab's. However, because the lab population is more sensitive to treatment, across our main PD game comparison the lab still outperforms both Prolific and MTurk.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。