多样性的代价
The Price of Diversity
摘要:
关于性别、种族和族裔的系统性偏见,往往是无意识的,在涉及个人选择的数据集中普遍存在。因此,社会发现,在这种环境中,以保持精英统治的方式减少偏见和实现多样性是一项挑战。我们提出了(a)一种新的优化方法,基于最佳翻转结果标签和训练分类模型,同时发现在选择过程中要做出的改变,以便在不显著影响精英统治的情况下实现多样性,以及(b)一种新的实施工具,采用最佳分类树来提供关于个体的哪些属性导致其标签翻转的见解,并帮助以人类决策者可以理解的方式改变当前的选择过程。我们目前的案例研究三个真实世界的数据集组成的假释,录取到酒吧和贷款的决定,并证明多样性的价格是低的,有时是负面的,也就是说,我们可以修改我们的选择过程中的方式,提高多样性,而不影响精英显着,有时改善它。
英文摘要:
Systemic bias with respect to gender, race and ethnicity, often unconscious, is prevalent in datasets involving choices among individuals. Consequently, society has found it challenging to alleviate bias and achieve diversity in a way that maintains meritocracy in such settings. We propose (a) a novel optimization approach based on optimally flipping outcome labels and training classification models simultaneously to discover changes to be made in the selection process so as to achieve diversity without significantly affecting meritocracy, and (b) a novel implementation tool employing optimal classification trees to provide insights on which attributes of individuals lead to flipping of their labels, and to help make changes in the current selection processes in a manner understandable by human decision makers. We present case studies on three real-world datasets consisting of parole, admissions to the bar and lending decisions, and demonstrate that the price of diversity is low and sometimes negative, that is we can modify our selection processes in a way that enhances diversity without affecting meritocracy significantly, and sometimes improving it.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。