手稿讨论:空间+空间混淆的新方法
Discussion of the manuscript: Spatial+ a novel approach to spatial confounding
摘要:
我祝贺Dupont,Wood和Augustin(DWA)提供了一种易于实现的方法,用于在空间混淆的情况下进行估计,并解决了该主题的一些复杂方面。该方法在空间基函数上回归感兴趣的协变量,并在结果回归中使用该模型的残差。作者表明,如果协变量不完全是空间的,这种方法导致一致的估计暴露和结果之间的条件关联。下面我讨论的概念和操作问题是基本的空间设置的推断:(i)目标量及其可解释性,(ii)协变量的非空间方面及其相对空间尺度,(iii)空间平滑的影响。虽然DWA提供了一些关于这些问题的见解,但我相信观众可能会从更深入的讨论中受益。在下文中,我将重点介绍研究人员有兴趣解释给定协变量与结果之间关系的设置。我将关注的协变量称为暴露量,以将其与其他变量区分开来。
英文摘要:
I congratulate Dupont, Wood and Augustin (DWA hereon) for providing an easy-to-implement method for estimation in the presence of spatial confounding, and for addressing some of the complicated aspects on the topic. The method regresses the covariate of interest on spatial basis functions and uses the residuals of this model in an outcome regression. The authors show that, if the covariate is not completely spatial, this approach leads to consistent estimation of the conditional association between the exposure and the outcome. Below I discuss conceptual and operational issues that are fundamental to inference in spatial settings: (i) the target quantity and its interpretability, (ii) the non-spatial aspect of covariates and their relative spatial scales, and (iii) the impact of spatial smoothing. While DWA provide some insights on these issues, I believe that the audience might benefit from a deeper discussion. In what follows, I focus on the setting where a researcher is interested in interpreting the relationship between a given covariate and an outcome. I refer to the covariate of interest as the exposure to differentiate it from the rest.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。