arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2106.15547astro-ph.SR
收藏

电影Barker and Astoul(2021)

Comments on Barker and Astoul (2021)

Caroline Terquem

摘要:

当相互作用双星的轨道周期相对于主星的对流时间尺度而言很短时,其潮汐演化是一个长期存在的问题。Terquem(2021)认为,当遵守这种时间排序方案时,从潮汐到对流的能量转移率(记为$D_R$)由与潮汐速度相关的平均雷诺应力和与对流相关的平均切变的乘积给出。在最近的回应中,Barker和Astoul(2021,以下简称BA 21)声称,$D_R$(这种形式)不能促进潮汐耗散。他们的分析是基于Boussinesq和滞弹性模型的研究。在这里,我们表明,BA21错误地识别负责潮汐和对流之间的能量转移的正确术语。因此,他们的滞弹性计算不能证明$D_R$公式作为潮汐和对流之间的能量损失耦合是无效的。BA21也在Boussinesq近似下进行了计算。在这里,他们声称$D_R$再次没有贡献是基于边界条件,不适用于任何从其表面辐射能量的恒星或行星,这是我们考虑的问题中的一个关键耗散过程。

英文摘要:

The tidal evolution of interacting binaries when the orbital period is short compared to the primary star's convective time scale is a problem of long-standing. Terquem (2021) has argued that, when this temporal ordering scheme is obeyed, the rate of energy transfer from tides to convection (denoted $D_R$) is given by the product of the averaged Reynolds stress associated with the tidal velocity and the mean shear associated with the convective flow. In a recent response, Barker and Astoul (2021, hereafter BA21) claim to show that $D_R$ (in this form) cannot contribute to tidal dissipation. Their analysis is based on a study of Boussinesq and anelastic models. Here, we demonstrate that BA21 misidentify the correct term responsible for energy transfer between tides and convection. As a consequence, their anelastic calculations do not prove that the $D_R$ formulation is invalidated as an energy-loss coupling between tides and convection. BA21 also carry out a calculation in the Boussinesq approximation. Here, their claim that $D_R$ once again does not contribute is based on boundary conditions that do not apply to any star or planet that radiates energy from its surface, which is a key dissipational process in the problem we consider.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑