arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2106.09329cs.SEcs.SI
收藏

网络科学,同质性和谁评论谁在Linux内核?

Network Science, Homophily and Who Reviews Who in the Linux Kernel?

José Apolinário Teixeira, Ville Leppänen, Sami Hyrynsalmi

摘要:

在本研究中,我们探讨同行评议在Linux的发展,通过借鉴网络理论和网络分析。我们构建了一个分析模型,它整合了同质性的社会学原则(即,个人与类似他人建立关系的关系倾向)与一般的同行评审,特别是开源软件的先前研究。我们发现一个相对较强的同质性倾向的维护者审查其他维护者,但一个类似的趋势是令人惊讶的缺乏关于开发人员的组织隶属关系。这样的结果反映了Linux内核开发所特有的规范、信仰、价值观、流程、政策和社会等级。我们的结果强调了网络理论生成机制在解释同行评审网络演变方面的力量。关于从业者对Linux商业化趋势的担忧,尽管企业的参与越来越多,但没有发现同行评审中的关系偏见。

英文摘要:

In this research, we investigate peer review in the development of Linux by drawing on network theory and network analysis. We frame an analytical model which integrates the sociological principle of homophily (i.e., the relational tendency of individuals to establish relationships with similar others) with prior research on peer-review in general and open-source software in particular. We found a relatively strong homophily tendency for maintainers to review other maintainers, but a comparable tendency is surprisingly absent regarding developers' organizational affiliation. Such results mirror the documented norms, beliefs, values, processes, policies, and social hierarchies that characterize the Linux kernel development. Our results underline the power of generative mechanisms from network theory to explain the evolution of peer review networks. Regarding practitioners' concern over the Linux commercialization trend, no relational bias in peer review was found albeit the increasing involvement of firms.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑