arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2106.06316stat.ME
收藏

我们该数活人还是死人?

Shall we count the living or the dead?

Anders Huitfeldt, Matthew P. Fox, Eleanor J. Murray, Asbjørn Hróbjartsson, Rhian M. Daniel

摘要:

在1958年的论文“我们应该数活着的还是死了的?,Mindel C.谢普斯提出了一个原则性的解决方案,以熟悉的问题,不对称的相对风险。我们提供了因果模型来澄清Sheps推理的范围和局限性,并表明她的首选相对风险的变体在某些生物学可解释的条件下在患者组之间是稳定的。当干预研究的结果必须被推广以支持风险特征与研究参与者不同的患者的临床决策时,这种稳定性是有用的。我们表明,Sheps的方法是一致的心理学和哲学研究的大量机构如何人类推理机进行因果信息从一个上下文中到另一个,它可以在实践中使用van der Laan等人的开关相对风险,或等效地,使用贝克和杰克逊的广义相对风险降低(GRRR)。

英文摘要:

In the 1958 paper "Shall we count the living or the dead?", Mindel C. Sheps proposed a principled solution to the familiar problem of asymmetry of the relative risk. We provide causal models to clarify the scope and limitations of Sheps' line of reasoning, and show that her preferred variant of the relative risk will be stable between patient groups under certain biologically interpretable conditions. Such stability is useful when findings from an intervention study must be generalized to support clinical decisions in patients whose risk profile differs from the participants in the study. We show that Sheps' approach is consistent with a substantial body of psychological and philosophical research on how human reasoners carry causal information from one context to another, and that it can be implemented in practice using van der Laan et al's Switch Relative Risk, or equivalently, using Baker and Jackson's Generalized Relative Risk Reduction (GRRR).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑