弦论、爱因斯坦和物理学的同一性:缺乏经验的理论评估
String theory, Einstein, and the identity of physics: Theory assessment in absence of the empirical
摘要:
弦理论家确信他们是实践物理学家。然而,他们最近的一些批评者否认了这一点。本文认为,这场冲突实际上是关于谁在理论物理学中拥有做出理性判断的权威。归根结底,冲突集中在一个问题上:谁是真正的物理学家?为了说明和理解关于正确实践和同一性的不同观点,我们讨论了弦理论家和他们的批评者对认识论美德和解释的不同理解,以及这些如何来源于爱因斯坦的传记。正如爱因斯坦被双方所宣称的那样,历史编纂提供了成功和不成功的非经验科学的例子。科学史还告诉我们,冲突的时代往往是创新的时代,在这种时代,新的学术身份可能会产生。与此同时,由于托马斯·库恩的贡献,历史学家对科学实践的认识划界和辩护的正式尝试和方法论处方采取了批判的态度。然而,这些现在正在非经验物理学的辩论中被考虑。
英文摘要:
String theorists are certain that they are practicing physicists. Yet, some of their recent critics deny this. This paper argues that this conflict is really about who holds authority in making rational judgment in theoretical physics. At bottom, the conflict centers on the question: who is a proper physicist? To illustrate and understand the differing opinions about proper practice and identity, we discuss different appreciations of epistemic virtues and explanation among string theorists and their critics, and how these have been sourced in accounts of Einstein's biography. Just as Einstein is claimed by both sides, historiography offers examples of both successful and unsuccessful non-empirical science. History of science also teaches that times of conflict are often times of innovation, in which novel scholarly identities may come into being. At the same time, since the contributions of Thomas Kuhn historians have developed a critical attitude towards formal attempts and methodological recipes for epistemic demarcation and justification of scientific practice. These are now, however, being considered in the debate on non-empirical physics.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。