对现代方法的反思:队列研究中用逆概率加权处理脱落时的方差估计
Reflection on modern methods: a note on variance estimation when using inverse probability weighting to handle attrition in cohort studies
摘要:
逆概率加权(IPW)方法用于处理队列研究中关联分析的损耗。它包括在一个给定的后续行动的受访者加权他们的参与概率的倒数。首先估计权重,然后在加权关联模型中使用。当使用IPW方法时,文献建议使用鲁棒方差估计器,而不是使用所谓的朴素方差估计器。然而,后者可能高估方差,因为权重被认为是已知的而不是估计的。在这篇文章中,我们开发,通过线性化技术,估计占权重估计阶段,并解释它是如何从天真和强大的方差估计不同。我们比较了三个方差估计,通过模拟几个MAR和MNAR方案。我们发现,鲁棒和线性化方差估计近似无偏,即使在MNAR的情况下。朴素方差估计严重低估了方差。我们鼓励研究人员在使用IPW方法时小心方差估计,避免天真的估计,并选择一个强大的或线性化的估计。提供R和SAS代码以在他们自己的研究中实现它们。
英文摘要:
The inverse probability weighting (IPW) method is used to handle attrition in association analyses derived from cohort studies. It consists in weighting the respondents at a given follow-up by their inverse probability to participate. Weights are estimated first and then used in a weighted association model. When the IPW method is used, instead of using a so-called na{ï}ve variance estimator, the literature recommends using a robust variance estimator. However, the latter may overestimate the variance because the weights are considered known rather than estimated. In this note, we develop, by a linearization technique, an estimator accounting for the weight estimation phase and explain how it differs from na{ï}ve and robust variance estimators. We compare the three variance estimators through simulations under several MAR and MNAR scenarios. We found that both the robust and linearized variance estimators were approximately unbiased, even in MNAR scenarios. The naive variance estimator severely underestimated the variance. We encourage researchers to be careful with variance estimation when using the IPW method, avoiding na{ï}ve estimator and opting for a robust or linearized estimator. R and SAS codes are provided to implement them in their own studies.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。