arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2104.13652econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

社会规范解释激励对亲社会行为的不一致影响

Social Norms Offer Explanation for Inconsistent Effects of Incentives on Prosocial Behavior

Caroline Graf, Eva-Maria Merz, Bianca Suanet, Pamala Wiepking

摘要:

当涉及到鼓励人们表现出亲社会行为时,激励措施的效果令人惊讶地不一致。古典经济理论认为,一种特定的行为在受到奖励时会变得更加普遍,但它很难解释为什么激励有时会适得其反。因此,最近的理论认为,声誉成本抵消了获得激励的好处,但激励的影响仍然无法解释,例如在不同的激励类型和国家。我们认为,社会规范可以为这些不一致提供一个解释。最终,社会规范决定了特定行为所产生的声誉成本或收益,因此激励效果的变化可能反映了规范的变化。我们实施了一个正式的亲社会行为模型整合社会规范,我们实证检验现实世界的献血亲社会行为。献血对于许多挽救生命的医疗程序至关重要,但也为我们的理论提供了一个理想的试验场:各国存在各种献血者激励政策,可以进行比较。我们的预注册分析表明,社会规范确实可以解释经济和时间激励对28个欧洲国家个人献血行为的不同影响。当激励规范更积极时,激励与更高水平的亲社会性相关。研究结果表明,社会规范在解释激励与亲社会行为之间的关系方面发挥着重要作用。更一般地说,我们的方法强调了整合经济学和行为科学理论的潜力,以产生新的见解,为政策制定带来切实的影响。

英文摘要:

Incentives have surprisingly inconsistent effects when it comes to encouraging people to behave prosocially. Classical economic theory, according to which a specific behavior becomes more prevalent when it is rewarded, struggles to explain why incentives sometimes backfire. More recent theories therefore posit a reputational cost offsetting the benefits of receiving an incentive -- yet unexplained effects of incentives remain, for instance across incentive types and countries. We propose that social norms can offer an explanation for these inconsistencies. Ultimately, social norms determine the reputational costs or benefits resulting from a given behavior, and thus variation in the effect of incentives may reflect variation in norms. We implemented a formal model of prosocial behavior integrating social norms, which we empirically tested on the real-world prosocial behavior of blood donation. Blood donation is essential for many life-saving medical procedures, but also presents an ideal testing ground for our theory: Various incentive policies for blood donors exist across countries, enabling a comparative approach. Our preregistered analyses reveal that social norms can indeed account for the varying effects of financial and time incentives on individual-level blood donation behavior across 28 European countries. Incentives are associated with higher levels of prosociality when norms regarding the incentive are more positive. The results indicate that social norms play an important role in explaining the relationship between incentives and prosocial behavior. More generally, our approach highlights the potential of integrating theory from across the economic and behavioral sciences to generate novel insights, with tangible consequences for policy-making.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑