将授粉激励措施与集体行动相结合,在农田中提供一揽子生态系统服务
Combining incentives for pollination with collective action to provide a bundle of ecosystem services in farmland
摘要:
一个多中心的方法来治理生态系统服务(ES),相互依存的ES提供者的集体行动相结合的个人激励措施是一个有前途的杠杆,克服ES的下降,并产生双赢的解决方案,在农业景观。在这项研究中,我们探讨了这种方法的有效性,重点是针对养蜂人或农民谁是在相互沟通或不管理授粉的激励措施。我们使用程式化的生物经济模型来模拟(i)通过授粉在集约化农业景观的相互依赖性和(ii)引入两个养蜂补贴和一个农药税的经济和生态影响。研究结果表明,激励措施产生了溢出效应,不仅影响到目标利益攸关方,而且影响到非目标利益攸关方以及景观,而且这种效应通过沟通得到放大。然而,没有一个模拟类型的多中心ES治理证明是可持续的整体:补贴表现出良好的经济,但低环境绩效,而税收导致经济损失,但有利于景观。基于这些结果,我们确定了基于利益相关者之间的沟通和激励措施的可持续ES治理的三个条件:(i)强烈的相互依赖性(即利益相关者的替代品很少),(ii)沟通的好处大于成本,(iii)激励ES驱动程序不会对其他ES造成损害。需要进一步研究,以系统化的个人支付和合作的组合是可持续的,在何种条件下。
英文摘要:
A polycentric approach to ecosystem service (ES) governance that combines individual incentives for interdependent ES providers with collective action is a promising lever to overcome the decline in ES and generate win-win solutions in agricultural landscapes. In this study, we explored the effectiveness of such an approach by focusing on incentives for managed pollination targeting either beekeepers or farmers who were either in communication with each other or not. We used a stylized bioeconomic model to simulate (i) the mutual interdependency through pollination in intensive agricultural landscapes and (ii) the economic and ecological impacts of introducing two beekeeping subsidies and one pesticide tax. The findings showed that incentives generated a spillover effect, affecting not only targeted stakeholders but non-targeted stakeholders as well as the landscape, and that this effect was amplified by communication. However, none of the simulated types of polycentric ES governance proved sustainable overall: subsidies showed excellent economic but low environmental performance, while the tax led to economic losses but was beneficial for the landscape. Based on these results, we identified three conditions for sustainable ES governance based on communication between stakeholders and incentives: (i) strong mutual interdependency (i.e. few alternatives exist for stakeholders), (ii) the benefits of communication outweigh the costs, and (iii) the incentivized ES drivers are not detrimental to other ES. Further research is needed to systematize which combination of individual payments and collaboration are sustainable in which conditions.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。