新的瞬变和VariableStars类别的解释多样性的历史透视
A Historical Perspective on the Diversity of Explanations for New Classes of Transient and VariableStars
摘要:
随着新的瞬变星和变星被发现,理论模型被建立起来,对这类恒星中的一些成员有效或无效,通常情况下,一些研究人员会根据奥卡姆剃刀提出论点,认为这类恒星中的所有成员都必须由首先成功解释其中一个物体的机制产生。这一假设也常常更加含蓄。回顾性分析清楚地表明,这种论证在很大程度上是失败的,在许多情况下,这种对虚假一致性的追求导致了更根本的天体物理学错误,其中一些在天文学史上非常突出。这一点的一个推论是,在许多情况下,解释瞬变的理论模型被证明是描述真实(但通常尚未发现)现象的模型,而不是它们首次应用的模型,尽管有微小的错误,导致模型似乎适合它没有描述的已知现象。这里提出了一组这样的事件的例子(其中一些对大多数天文学家来说是非常熟悉的),以及为什么会发生这种现象的讨论,它如何在目前表现出来。还将讨论为什么以及何时勘测设计导致了各种瞬态机制的立即分离,通常是通过相对于{ \it检测}一类新对象所需的某种方式被压制。
英文摘要:
As new classes of transients and variable stars are discovered, and theoretical models are established to work or not to work for a few members of the class, it is often the case that some researchers will make arguments on the basis of Occam's razor that all members of the class must be produced by whichever mechanism first successfully explained one of the objects. It is also frequent that this assumption will be more more implicitly. Retrospective analysis shows rather clearly that this argument fails a large fraction of the time, and in many cases, this search for false consistency has led to more fundamental astrophysical errors, a few of which are quite prominent in the history of astronomy. A corollary of this is that on numerous occasions, theoretical models to explain transients have turned out to be models that describe real (but often not yet discovered) phenomenona other than the ones to which they have first been applied, albeit with minor errors that caused the model to appear to fit to a known phenomenon it did not describe. A set of examples of such events is presented here (some of which will be quite familiar to most astronomers), along with a discussion of why this phenomenon occurs, how it may be manifesting itself at the present time. Some discussion will also be made of why and when survey designs have led to immediate separation of various transient mechanisms, generally by being overpowered in some way relative to what is needed to {\it detect} a new class of objects.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。