arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2104.02604q-bio.BMcs.LGq-bio.QM
收藏

在QSAR建模中使用分子嵌入:是否有区别?

Using Molecular Embeddings in QSAR Modeling: Does it Make a Difference?

Institute for Computer Science and Engineering (UNS-CONICET)(计算机科学与工程研究所(UNS-CONICET));Dalhousie University(达尔豪斯大学)

María Virginia Sabando, Ignacio Ponzoni, Evangelos E. Milios, Axel J. Soto

摘要:

随着深度学习在药物发现中的巩固,已经提出了几种用于学习分子表示的新算法。尽管社区的兴趣在开发新的方法学习分子嵌入和他们的理论优势,比较分子嵌入彼此和传统的表示是不简单的,这反过来又阻碍了选择一个合适的表示QSAR建模的过程。这个问题背后的一个原因是很难对不同的现有嵌入方法进行公平和彻底的比较,这需要在各种数据集和训练场景上进行大量实验。为了缩小这一差距,我们回顾了文献中的分子嵌入方法,并复制了文献中最近提出的三种无监督和两种监督的分子嵌入技术。我们比较了这五种方法在QSAR场景中使用不同的分类和回归数据集的性能。我们还比较了这些表示传统的分子表示,即分子描述符和指纹。与预期结果相反,我们的实验设置由超过25,000个训练模型和统计测试组成,显示使用分子嵌入的预测性能并没有显著超过传统表示。虽然监督嵌入与使用传统分子表示的嵌入相比产生了竞争性结果,但无监督嵌入往往比传统表示表现得更差。我们的研究结果强调,需要进行仔细的比较和分析不同的嵌入技术之前,使用它们在药物设计任务,并激发讨论的潜力,分子嵌入在计算机辅助药物设计。

英文摘要:

With the consolidation of deep learning in drug discovery, several novel algorithms for learning molecular representations have been proposed. Despite the interest of the community in developing new methods for learning molecular embeddings and their theoretical benefits, comparing molecular embeddings with each other and with traditional representations is not straightforward, which in turn hinders the process of choosing a suitable representation for QSAR modeling. A reason behind this issue is the difficulty of conducting a fair and thorough comparison of the different existing embedding approaches, which requires numerous experiments on various datasets and training scenarios. To close this gap, we reviewed the literature on methods for molecular embeddings and reproduced three unsupervised and two supervised molecular embedding techniques recently proposed in the literature. We compared these five methods concerning their performance in QSAR scenarios using different classification and regression datasets. We also compared these representations to traditional molecular representations, namely molecular descriptors and fingerprints. As opposed to the expected outcome, our experimental setup consisting of over 25,000 trained models and statistical tests revealed that the predictive performance using molecular embeddings did not significantly surpass that of traditional representations. While supervised embeddings yielded competitive results compared to those using traditional molecular representations, unsupervised embeddings tended to perform worse than traditional representations. Our results highlight the need for conducting a careful comparison and analysis of the different embedding techniques prior to using them in drug design tasks, and motivate a discussion about the potential of molecular embeddings in computer-aided drug design.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑