arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2103.14559physics.comp-phphysics.med-phstat.APstat.ME
收藏

离散不确定性的量化:两种范式的比较

On the quantification of discretization uncertainty: comparison of two paradigms

Julien Bect, Souleymane Zio, Guillaume Perrin, Claire Cannamela, Emmanuel Vazquez

摘要:

基于偏微分方程(PDE)或积分微分方程的数值模型在工程和科学中无处不在,使得理解或设计物理实验昂贵(有时不可能)的系统成为可能。这种模型通常使用离散化方法,如有限差分或有限元法,构造基本连续方程的近似解。由此产生的离散化误差引入了一种形式的不确定性的精确但未知的值的任何数量的兴趣(QoI),这影响了预测的数值模型以及其他来源的不确定性,如参数不确定性或模型不足。首先,基于Richardson外推技术,提出了由P. Roache在计算流体动力学(CFD)领域提出的网格收敛指数(GCI)。另一种方法,基于高斯过程模型的贝叶斯推断,最近在统计文献中引入。在这项工作中,我们提出并比较这两种范式的离散化不确定性的量化,这已经在不同的科学界开发,并评估潜在的年轻贝叶斯方法提供一个替代完善的GCI为基础的方法,更好的概率基础。该方法的说明和评估的两个标准的测试案例,从文献(盖驱动腔体和Brachshenko梁)。

英文摘要:

Numerical models based on partial differential equations (PDE), or integro-differential equations, are ubiquitous in engineering and science, making it possible to understand or design systems for which physical experiments would be expensive-sometimes impossible-to carry out. Such models usually construct an approximate solution of the underlying continuous equations, using discretization methods such as finite differences or the finite elements method. The resulting discretization error introduces a form of uncertainty on the exact but unknown value of any quantity of interest (QoI), which affects the predictions of the numerical model alongside other sources of uncertainty such as parametric uncertainty or model inadequacy. The present article deals with the quantification of this discretization uncertainty.A first approach to this problem, now standard in the V\&V (Verification and Validation) literature, uses the grid convergence index (GCI) originally proposed by P. Roache in the field of computational fluid dynamics (CFD), which is based on the Richardson extrapolation technique. Another approach, based on Bayesian inference with Gaussian process models, was more recently introduced in the statistical literature. In this work we present and compare these two paradigms for the quantification of discretization uncertainty, which have been developped in different scientific communities, and assess the potential of the-younger-Bayesian approach to provide a replacement for the well-established GCI-based approach, with better probabilistic foundations. The methods are illustrated and evaluated on two standard test cases from the literature (lid-driven cavity and Timoshenko beam).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑