arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2103.10570cs.SE
收藏

理解ICT项目启动的原因和方式:基于Repertory Grid的分析

Towards an Understanding of Why and How ICT Projects Are Initiated: Analysis via Repertory Grid

Htike Htike Wut Yi, Stephen G. MacDonell

摘要:

当代商业创新越来越依赖于信息和通信技术解决方案。由于信息和通信技术举措一般通过项目实施,信息和通信技术项目的管理受到越来越多的审查。信息和通信技术项目继续失败;因此,虽然对信通技术项目管理的研究确实有所增加,但研究和实践仍面临许多挑战。许多研究涉及信通技术项目的执行和管理以及可能与项目成果有关的许多因素。然而,很少有人考虑到信息和通信技术项目的启动以及在生存周期之前的早期阶段作出的关键决定。因此,本研究的主要目的是调查信息和通信技术项目,特别侧重于他们的启动。在这样做的时候,我们希望了解为什么要启动信息和通信技术项目,以及它们是如何从想法或建议变成有支持的现实的。本研究采用半结构化访谈和储备网格数据汇集与分析相结合的方法,调查并验证了影响个别IT经理项目启动决策的激励因素以及他们从想法到实施项目的转换方法。我们的研究结果表明,在这个早期阶段做出的决策确实有多种潜在原因,并且有一些特别常见的决策驱动因素。有些是预期的,因为它们与建议的最佳做法相对应。例如,大多数项目的动机是希望实现效率或节省成本,往往使用成本效益分析来评估其潜力。其他结果更令人惊讶-竞争对手的压力并不是我们分析中ICT项目启动的常见驱动力。毫不奇怪,当项目规模较大、知名度较高时,更经常使用正式评价方法来评估项目提案。(节录)

英文摘要:

Contemporary business innovation relies increasingly on information and communications technology (ICT) solutions. As ICT initiatives are generally implemented via projects the management of ICT projects has come under increasing scrutiny. ICT projects continue to fail; as a result, while research in ICT project management has indeed increased, many challenges for research and practice remain. Many studies have addressed the execution and management of ICT projects and the many factors that might relate to project outcomes. Very few, however, have considered ICT project initiation and the crucial decisions made at that very early, pre-life cycle stage. The primary intent of this research is therefore to investigate ICT projects with a particular focus on their initiation. In doing so we wished to understand why ICT projects are started, and how they are moved from idea or proposal to supported reality. A combination of semi-structured interviews and the repertory grid data collection and analysis method was employed to investigate and validate the motivating factors that influence individual IT Managers' project initiation decisions and the methods they use to transition from idea to enacted project. Our results showed that there are indeed multiple underlying reasons for the decisions made at this early stage and that there are some especially common decision drivers. Some were expected, in the sense that they mapped to recommended best practice. For instance, most projects are motivated by a desire to achieve efficiencies or cost savings, and their potential tends to be assessed using cost benefit analysis. Other results were more surprising - competitor pressure was not a common driver for ICT project initiation in our analysis. Unsurprisingly, formal evaluation methods are more frequently used to assess project proposals when those projects are larger and higher profile. (Abridged)

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑