arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2103.05885cs.DL
收藏

我们从OpenReview中学到了什么?

What Have We Learned from OpenReview?

Gang Wang, Qi Peng, Yanfeng Zhang, Mingyang Zhang

摘要:

大多数计算机科学会议都采用匿名同行评审。OpenReview就是这样一个平台,旨在促进同行评审过程的开放性。论文、(Meta)评论、反驳和最终决定都向公众发布。我们从OpenReview平台收集了5,527份提交和16,853条评论。我们还从Google Scholar收集了这些提交的引文数据,并从arXiv.org收集了非同行评审版本。通过深入了解这些数据,我们有几个有趣的发现,可以帮助理解公众可访问的双盲同行评审过程的有效性。我们的研究结果可能有助于撰写论文,审查它,并决定其接受。

英文摘要:

Anonymous peer review is used by the great majority of computer science conferences. OpenReview is such a platform that aims to promote openness in peer review process. The paper, (meta) reviews, rebuttals, and final decisions are all released to public. We collect 5,527 submissions and their 16,853 reviews from the OpenReview platform. We also collect these submissions' citation data from Google Scholar and their non-peer-reviewed versions from arXiv.org. By acquiring deep insights into these data, we have several interesting findings that could help understand the effectiveness of the public-accessible double-blind peer review process. Our results can potentially help writing a paper, reviewing it, and deciding on its acceptance.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑