arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2103.05479cs.CY
收藏

PEAK SHIFT ESTIMATION一种估计选择性遗漏检查数据排序的新方法

PEAK SHIFT ESTIMATION A novel method to estimate ranking of selectively omitted examination data

Satoshi Takahashi, Masaki Kitazawa, Ryoma Aoki, Atsushi Yoshikawa

摘要:

本文以考生选择性跳级的考试结果为研究对象,对这两种考试的难度水平进行比较。我们称之为“选择性省略的考试数据”。这种类型的考试的例子有大学入学考试、认证考试和学生求职活动的结果。我们可以知道每项考试的收生人数和机构,但不能知道考生的身份。没有研究关注这类数据。当我们知道这些考试的难度水平,我们可以得到一个新的指标来评估组织能力,有多少学生通过,考试的难度。这一指数将反映他们的教育成果,与考试观点相对应。因此,我们提出了一种新的方法,峰移估计,估计考试的难度水平的基础上选择性省略考试数据。首先,我们应用峰值偏移估计的模拟数据,并证明峰值偏移估计估计的排名顺序的大学入学考试的难度水平非常强大。Peak Shift Estimation也适用于估计大学的多层次规模,即A,B,C和D排名大学入学考试。我们将峰值偏移估计应用于东京都市圈的真实数据,并证明难度等级排名与真实排名之间的等级相关系数为0.844,80%的大学之间的差异在25个等级之内。因此,峰移估计的准确性较低,必须加以改进;然而,这是第一次研究,重点放在排名选择性省略的检查数据,因此,我们的贡献之一是阐明这种方法。

英文摘要:

In this paper, we focus on examination results when examinees selectively skip examinations, to compare the difficulty levels of these examinations. We call the resultant data 'selectively omitted examination data' Examples of this type of examination are university entrance examinations, certification examinations, and the outcome of students' job-hunting activities. We can learn the number of students accepted for each examination and organization but not the examinees' identity. No research has focused on this type of data. When we know the difficulty level of these examinations, we can obtain a new index to assess organization ability, how many students pass, and the difficulty of the examinations. This index would reflect the outcomes of their education corresponding to perspectives on examinations. Therefore, we propose a novel method, Peak Shift Estimation, to estimate the difficulty level of an examination based on selectively omitted examination data. First, we apply Peak Shift Estimation to the simulation data and demonstrate that Peak Shift Estimation estimates the rank order of the difficulty level of university entrance examinations very robustly. Peak Shift Estimation is also suitable for estimating a multi-level scale for universities, that is, A, B, C, and D rank university entrance examinations. We apply Peak Shift Estimation to real data of the Tokyo metropolitan area and demonstrate that the rank correlation coefficient between difficulty level ranking and true ranking is 0.844 and that the difference between 80 percent of universities is within 25 ranks. The accuracy of Peak Shift Estimation is thus low and must be improved; however, this is the first study to focus on ranking selectively omitted examination data, and therefore, one of our contributions is to shed light on this method.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑