arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2103.02052cs.CYcs.DL
收藏

研究全球化中的趋同与不平等

Convergence and Inequality in Research Globalization

Saurabh Mishra, Kuansan Wang

摘要:

追赶效应和马太效应提供了对全球化的相反描述:前者预测最终会趋同,因为由于互补资源的自由交换,穷人可以比富人增长得更快,而后者则会加深贫富之间的不平等。为了了解这些对研究全球化的影响,我们基于过去40年来涵盖218个国家/地区STEM研究的学术和专利出版物进行了深入研究,涵盖了超过5500万篇学术文章和17亿次引用。这项调查的独特之处在于,使用一种新的基于机器学习的测量方法(称为显着性),同时检查研究成果及其在同一数据集中的影响,以减轻量化研究影响时的内在偏见。结果表明,这两种影响实际上是同时发生的:有明确的迹象表明,高收入和中上收入国家在STEM领域的趋同,但差距正在扩大,将中低收入地区与高收入地区隔离开来。此外,STEM子领域之间的收敛速度明显不同,人工智能(AI)的高度战略性领域夹在医学和材料科学等领域之间,占据了光谱的两端。这些数据支持了这样一种观点,即当低收入国家的组织与那些已经占主导地位的组织建立实质性的研究合作时,对马太效应的主要解释,即偏好依恋理论,实际上可以促进追赶效应。数据有力地表明,这种合作使所有相关方受益,在材料科学领域可以看到角色逆转的案例,在材料科学领域可以观察到最先进的趋同迹象。

英文摘要:

The catch-up effect and the Matthew effect offer opposing characterizations of globalization: the former predicts an eventual convergence as the poor can grow faster than the rich due to free exchanges of complementary resources, while the latter, a deepening inequality between the rich and the poor. To understand these effects on the globalization of research, we conduct an in-depth study based on scholarly and patent publications covering STEM research from 218 countries/regions over the past four decades, covering more than 55 million scholarly articles and 1.7 billion citations. Unique to this investigation is the simultaneous examination of both the research output and its impact in the same data set, using a novel machine learning based measure, called saliency, to mitigate the intrinsic biases in quantifying the research impact. The results show that the two effects are in fact co-occurring: there are clear indications of convergence among the high income and upper middle income countries across the STEM fields, but a widening gap is developing that segregates the lower middle and low income regions from the higher income regions. Furthermore, the rate of convergence varies notably among the STEM sub-fields, with the highly strategic area of Artificial Intelligence (AI) sandwiched between fields such as Medicine and Materials Science that occupy the opposite ends of the spectrum. The data support the argument that a leading explanation of the Matthew effect, namely, the preferential attachment theory, can actually foster the catch-up effect when organizations from lower income countries forge substantial research collaborations with those already dominant. The data resoundingly show such collaborations benefit all parties involved, and a case of role reversal can be seen in the Materials Science field where the most advanced signs of convergence are observed.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑