对“复杂几何中标量通量非齐次Neumann边界条件的体积惩罚”一文的评论
Critique on "Volume penalization for inhomogeneous Neumann boundary conditions modeling scalar flux in complicated geometry"
摘要:
在这封信中,我们提供反例来证明,它是可能的,以保留二阶精度使用樱井等人。的方法,即使不同的通量边界条件施加在多个接口,不符合笛卡尔网格。在我们的测试问题中,我们考虑了连续和不连续的指示函数。两个指示函数对这里考虑的问题都产生类似的收敛速度。我们还发现,在樱井等人的一些情况下,准确度结果的顺序是不可重现的。这是证明重新考虑相同的一维和二维泊松问题解决樱井等人。在这封信中。本文所示的结果表明,Sakurai等人的基于通量的VP方法的空间精度阶数介于$\mathcal{O}$(1)和$\mathcal{O}$(2)之间,并且取决于潜在的问题/模型。空间精度顺序不能简单地推导出一个先验的基础上强加的通量值,形状,或网格一致性的接口,在樱井等人的结论。需要进一步分析,以了解空间收敛速度的通量为基础的VP方法。
英文摘要:
In this letter, we provide counter-examples to demonstrate that it is possible to retain second-order accuracy using Sakurai et al.'s method, even when different flux boundary conditions are imposed on multiple interfaces that do not conform to the Cartesian grid. We consider both continuous and discontinuous indicator functions in our test problems. Both indicator functions yield a similar convergence rate for the problems considered here. We also find that the order of accuracy results for some of the cases presented in Sakurai et al. are not reproducible. This is demonstrated by re-considering the same one- and two-dimensional Poisson problems solved in Sakurai et al. in this letter. The results shown in this letter demonstrate that the spatial order of accuracy of the flux-based VP approach of Sakurai et al. is between $\mathcal{O}$(1) and $\mathcal{O}$(2), and it depends on the underlying problem/model. The spatial order of accuracy cannot simply be deduced a priori based on the imposed flux values, shapes, or grid-conformity of the interfaces, as concluded in Sakurai et al. Further analysis is required to understand the spatial convergence rate of the flux-based VP method.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。