arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2101.12267stat.AP
收藏

现金保释决策的贝叶斯模型

A Bayesian Model of Cash Bail Decisions

Joshua Williams, J. Zico Kolter

摘要:

使用现金保释作为审前拘留被告的机制是一种经常受到批评的制度,许多人认为这违反了“无罪推定”的原则。“许多研究试图了解现金保释使用的长期影响和现金保释分配的不同比率,以及人口统计学上的差异(种族、性别等)。然而,这样的工作往往容易受到超边际性问题的影响--我们观察到的数据只能描述平均结果,而不是与边际决策相关的结果。在这项工作中,我们解决这个问题,通过创建一个层次贝叶斯模型的现金保释分配。具体来说,我们的方法模型现金保释决定作为一个概率的过程,法官平衡分配现金保释的相对成本与被告可能跳过开庭日期的成本,这些跳过概率估计的基础上的功能的个别案件。然后,我们使用蒙特卡罗推断抽样分布在这些成本为不同的地方法官和不同的种族。我们将这个模型与我们在宾夕法尼亚州阿勒格尼县和费城县收集的超过50,000起法庭案件的数据集相匹配。我们对50名不同法官的分析表明,他们一致更有可能分配现金保释给黑人被告而不是白人被告,即使有相同的可能性跳过出庭。这一分析对现金保释做法的公平性提出了进一步的问题,无论其基本的法律理由如何。

英文摘要:

The use of cash bail as a mechanism for detaining defendants pre-trial is an often-criticized system that many have argued violates the presumption of "innocent until proven guilty." Many studies have sought to understand both the long-term effects of cash bail's use and the disparate rate of cash bail assignments along demographic lines (race, gender, etc). However, such work is often susceptible to problems of infra-marginality -- that the data we observe can only describe average outcomes, and not the outcomes associated with the marginal decision. In this work, we address this problem by creating a hierarchical Bayesian model of cash bail assignments. Specifically, our approach models cash bail decisions as a probabilistic process whereby judges balance the relative costs of assigning cash bail with the cost of defendants potentially skipping court dates, and where these skip probabilities are estimated based upon features of the individual case. We then use Monte Carlo inference to sample the distribution over these costs for different magistrates and across different races. We fit this model to a data set we have collected of over 50,000 court cases in the Allegheny and Philadelphia counties in Pennsylvania. Our analysis of 50 separate judges shows that they are uniformly more likely to assign cash bail to black defendants than to white defendants, even given identical likelihood of skipping a court appearance. This analysis raises further questions about the equity of the practice of cash bail, irrespective of its underlying legal justification.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑