安全帽和Bungaloo:比较课堂上的众包设计反馈与同行设计反馈
Hardhats and Bungaloos: Comparing Crowdsourced Design Feedback with Peer Design Feedback in the Classroom
摘要:
反馈是设计教育的一个重要方面,众包已成为大规模获取反馈的便捷方式。在本文中,我们研究如何众包的设计反馈相比,同行的设计反馈在一个面向设计的人机交互类和两个指标:感知质量和感知公平性。我们还研究了众包反馈的感知货币价值,这与典型的以请求者为中心的众包平台上的劳动力价值观形成了有趣的对比。我们的研究结果表明,学生(N=106)认为众包的设计反馈不如同行的设计反馈在多种方式。然而,他们也发现了同龄人无法提供的在线人群的各种积极方面。我们讨论了研究结果的意义,并提供建议,在HCI和其他研究人员有兴趣在人群反馈系统使用人群作为一个潜在的补充,以同行的教师。
英文摘要:
Feedback is an important aspect of design education, and crowdsourcing has emerged as a convenient way to obtain feedback at scale. In this paper, we investigate how crowdsourced design feedback compares to peer design feedback within a design-oriented HCI class and across two metrics: perceived quality and perceived fairness. We also examine the perceived monetary value of crowdsourced feedback, which provides an interesting contrast to the typical requester-centric view of the value of labor on crowdsourcing platforms. Our results reveal that the students (N=106) perceived the crowdsourced design feedback as inferior to peer design feedback in multiple ways. However, they also identified various positive aspects of the online crowds that peers cannot provide. We discuss the meaning of the findings and provide suggestions for teachers in HCI and other researchers interested in crowd feedback systems on using crowds as a potential complement to peers.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。