arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2101.06149econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

远离琼斯向前移动:迁移,信息差距和信号

Moving Away from the Joneses to Move Ahead: Migration, Information Gap and Signalling

Shihas Abdul-Razak, Upasak Das, Rupayan Pal

摘要:

通过消费有形商品来显示社会地位,往往被视为个人寻求效仿或与社区内其他人相比提升的一种方式。本文利用印度喀拉拉邦的代表性移民调查数据,评估了跨国移民对有形商品消费的影响。我们利用在邻近地区和宗教社区的移民网络中的合理的外生变化来解释潜在的内生。研究结果表明,即使在控制家庭收入之后,移民对炫耀性消费也有显著的积极和强大的影响。就机制而言,虽然我们无法排除相关的基于品味的偏好变化以及推动地位商品支出的同龄群体效应,但我们观察到这些渠道的影响有限。我们提出的一个潜在的渠道是永久居民之间的信息差距,对一个外来移民的收入水平,这是由他们利用信号更高的社会地位。我们通过一个理论模型来探索这一渠道,在这个模型中,我们将迁移、信息差距和状态良好的消费联系起来。我们得出了一组条件来测试是否移民表现出势利或循规蹈矩的行为。经验观察表明,势利行为占主导地位。

英文摘要:

Signalling social status through the consumption of visible goods has often been perceived as a way in which individuals seek to emulate or move up compared to others within the community. Using representative migration survey data from the Indian state of Kerala, this paper assesses the impact of transnational migration on consumption of visible goods. We utilize the plausibly exogenous variation in migration networks in the neighbourhood and religious communities to account for the potential endogeneity. The findings indicate a significantly positive and robust effect of migration on conspicuous consumption, even after controlling for household income. In terms of the mechanisms, while we are unable to rule out the associated taste-based changes in preferences and the peer group effects driving up the spending on status goods, we observe only limited effects of these channels. A potential channel that we propose is information gap among permanent residents about the income levels of an out-migrant, which is leveraged by them to signal higher status in society. We explore this channel through a theoretical model where we connect migration, information gap and status good consumption. We derive a set of conditions to test whether migrants exhibit snobbish or conformist behaviour. Empirical observations indicate predominance of a snobbish behaviour.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑