arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2011.12709cs.CR
收藏

解决网络安全数据共享障碍,通过合作生产方法实现数据共享,从而扩大网络安全

Resolving the cybersecurity Data Sharing Paradox to scale up cybersecurity via a co-production approach towards data sharing

Amir Atapour-Abarghouei, Andrew Stephen McGough, David Stanley Wall

摘要:

随着网络犯罪分子扩大他们的行动以增加利润或造成更大的伤害,我们认为,同样需要通过扩大网络安全来应对他们的威胁。为了实现这一目标,我们必须通过克服网络安全数据共享悖论,制定一种合作的数据汇集和共享方法。这就是我们都同意问题的定义和最终目标(改善网络安全和摆脱网络犯罪),但我们对如何实现它存在分歧,并且未能有效地合作。这一悖论的核心是公共利益不同于私人利益。因此,行业和执法部门在寻求解决符合自身利益的事件时,对网络安全问题采取了不同的方法,这体现在双方以及其他相关方(如网络安全研究人员)之间的不同数据共享做法中。我们提出的一个大问题是,这些利益能否协调一致,以发展一种跨学科的合作和共享数据的方法。从本质上讲,这三个国家必须共同承担问题,以便共同制定解决方案。我们认为,存在一些具有良好实践的运营模式,为可能的解决方案提供指导,特别是整合,匿名和分析数据的多个第三方所有权组织。为了推进这一工作,我们建议采取切实可行的解决办法,在部门基础上组织共同生产的数据汇集,但承认还必须制定和商定数据汇集的共同标准。我们提出了一套初步的最佳实践,建立合作和共享数据,并认为这些最佳实践需要开发和标准化,以减轻悖论。

英文摘要:

As cybercriminals scale up their operations to increase their profits or inflict greater harm, we argue that there is an equal need to respond to their threats by scaling up cybersecurity. To achieve this goal, we have to develop a co-productive approach towards data collection and sharing by overcoming the cybersecurity data sharing paradox. This is where we all agree on the definition of the problem and end goal (improving cybersecurity and getting rid of cybercrime), but we disagree about how to achieve it and fail to work together efficiently. At the core of this paradox is the observation that public interests differ from private interests. As a result, industry and law enforcement take different approaches to the cybersecurity problem as they seek to resolve incidents in their own interests, which manifests in different data sharing practices between both and also other interested parties, such as cybersecurity researchers. The big question we ask is can these interests be reconciled to develop an interdisciplinary approach towards co-operation and sharing data. In essence, all three will have to co-own the problem in order to co-produce a solution. We argue that a few operational models with good practices exist that provide guides to a possible solution, especially multiple third-party ownership organisations which consolidate, anonymise and analyse data. To take this forward, we suggest the practical solution of organising co-productive data collection on a sectoral basis, but acknowledge that common standards for data collection will also have to be developed and agreed upon. We propose an initial set of best practices for building collaborations and sharing data and argue that these best practices need to be developed and standardised in order to mitigate the paradox.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑