有偿与假设时间偏好相同:实验室、实地和在线证据
Paid and hypothetical time preferences are the same: Lab, field and online evidence
AI总结:
本文通过西班牙实验室、尼日利亚实地及在线概率支付三项研究,检验多重价格列表任务中支付方式对时间偏好引致的影响,发现假设支付可替代真实支付,但概率性支付不行。
摘要:
在数十年的经济学实验之后,使用假设而非真实的决策激励仍存在争议。标准的激励实验因参与者的报酬而产生大量货币成本,通常还伴随物流成本。在涉及未来支付的时间偏好实验中,真实支付尤其成问题。由于在实验任务中,即时奖励的交易成本往往低于延迟奖励,加上其他问题,(拟)双曲函数形式无法被准确估计。如果假设支付能够提供准确数据,而且还能避免交易成本问题,会怎样?本文检验在标准的多重价格列表任务中,使用假设支付与真实支付是否会影响短期和长期贴现的引致结果。研究还考虑了十分之一参与者获得支付的概率性支付方案。我们分析了来自三项研究的数据:西班牙的一项实验室实验、尼日利亚一项统计功效充分的实地实验,以及一项聚焦概率性支付的在线扩展实验。结果表明,有偿与假设的时间偏好大体相同,因此假设奖励是真实奖励的良好替代。然而,数据表明概率性支付并非如此。
英文摘要:
The use of hypothetical instead of real decision-making incentives remains under debate after decades of economic experiments. Standard incentivized experiments involve substantial monetary costs due to participants' earnings and often logistic costs as well. In time preferences experiments, which involve future payments, real payments are particularly problematic. Since immediate rewards frequently have lower transaction costs than delayed rewards in experimental tasks, among other issues, (quasi)hyperbolic functional forms cannot be accurately estimated. What if hypothetical payments provide accurate data which, moreover, avoid transaction cost problems? In this paper, we test whether the use of hypothetical - versus real - payments affects the elicitation of short-term and long-term discounting in a standard multiple price list task. One-out-of-ten participants probabilistic payment schemes are also considered. We analyze data from three studies: a lab experiment in Spain, a well-powered field experiment in Nigeria, and an online extension focused on probabilistic payments. Our results indicate that paid and hypothetical time preferences are mostly the same and, therefore, that hypothetical rewards are a good alternative to real rewards. However, our data suggest that probabilistic payments are not.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。