arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2010.06567stat.AP
收藏

条件把握度和朋友:验证性试验中(非)计划、非盲态样本量重新计算的原因和方法

Conditional Power and Friends: The Why and How of (Un)planned, Unblinded Sample Size Recalculations in Confirmatory Trials

Kevin Kunzmann, Michael J. Grayling, Kim M. Lee, David S. Robertson, Kaspar Rufibach, James M. S. Wason

摘要:

根据审判过程中积累的证据调整审判的最终样本量是解决计划不确定性的自然方法。具有自适应样本量的设计需要考虑其可选停止,以保证严格的第一类错误率控制。文献中提出了在初始样本量发生计划外变化后保持第一类错误率控制的各种不同方法。这使得在监管背景下进行中期分析以重新计算样本量变得可行。由于样本量通常通过基于试验把握度的论证确定,因此中期分析提出了如何根据累积信息确定最终样本量的问题。有条件权力是在这种情况下经常提出的一个概念。由于它取决于未知的效应大小,我们采取严格的估计角度,并比较假设的条件功率,观察到的条件功率和预测功率相对于其属性作为未知条件功率的估计。然后,我们证明,预先计划的中期分析使用方法计划外的中期分析是无效的,自然会导致最佳的两阶段设计的概念。我们的结论是,计划外的设计调整只应作为反应进行试验外部新的证据,操作需要违反最初选择的设计,或事后的客观标准的变化。最后,我们表明,通常讨论的样本量重新计算规则可能会导致矛盾的结果,并提出两种替代方法来应对新出现的试验外部证据。

英文摘要:

Adapting the final sample size of a trial to the evidence accruing during the trial is a natural way to address planning uncertainty. Designs with adaptive sample size need to account for their optional stopping to guarantee strict type-I error-rate control. A variety of different methods to maintain type-I error-rate control after unplanned changes of the initial sample size have been proposed in the literature. This makes interim analyses for the purpose of sample size recalculation feasible in a regulatory context. Since the sample size is usually determined via an argument based on the power of the trial, an interim analysis raises the question of how the final sample size should be determined conditional on the accrued information. Conditional power is a concept often put forward in this context. Since it depends on the unknown effect size, we take a strict estimation perspective and compare assumed conditional power, observed conditional power, and predictive power with respect to their properties as estimators of the unknown conditional power. We then demonstrate that pre-planning an interim analysis using methodology for unplanned interim analyses is ineffective and naturally leads to the concept of optimal two-stage designs. We conclude that unplanned design adaptations should only be conducted as reaction to trial-external new evidence, operational needs to violate the originally chosen design, or post hoc changes in the objective criterion. Finally, we show that commonly discussed sample size recalculation rules can lead to paradoxical outcomes and propose two alternative ways of reacting to newly emerging trial-external evidence.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑