arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2010.03582astro-ph.CO
收藏

比较{ \it Planck}- ESZ团簇的大样本的不同质量估计

Comparing different mass estimators for a large subsample of the {\it Planck}-ESZ clusters

L. Lovisari, S. Ettori, M. Sereno, G. Schellenberger, W. R. Forman, F. Andrade-Santos, C. Jones

摘要:

总质量可以说是对星系团进行宇宙学研究的最基本属性。我们调查目前的差异,通过独立的X射线,弱透镜和动力学研究获得的质量估计。我们将差异量化为平均比值1- $b$ =M $_{\rm HE}$ /M $_{\rm WL,dyn}$,其中HE是指从X射线观测获得的流体静力学质量,WL是指弱透镜测量的结果,dyn是指从速度色散或焦散技术获得的质量估计。最近由独立小组报告的X射线质量显示平均差异小于$\sim$ 10 $\%$,在研究流体静力学偏差时,可以归因于X射线分析的差异,对系统学构成了很大的限制。我们的X射线质量和LC $^2$ -单星表中弱透镜质量之间的平均比值为1- $b$ =0.74 $\pm$ 0.06。然而,从不同项目的WL质量推断的平均质量比变化很大,APEX-SZ显示出与零一致的偏差(1- $b$ =1.02 $\pm$ 0.12),LoCuSS和CCCP/MENeaCS显示显著差异(分别为1- $b$ =0.76 $\pm$ 0.09和1- $b$ =0.77 $\pm$ 0.10),WtG指向最大偏差(1- $b$ =0.61 $\pm$ 0.12)。与WL结果不一致的是,动力学质量测量与X射线流体静力学质量显示出更好的一致性,尽管当使用松弛或扰动簇时存在显着差异。使用不同的质量估计得到的不同的比率表明,仍然有系统,不占在所有的技术用于恢复集群质量。这就妨碍了对星系团中流体静力学质量偏差水平的严格限制的确定。

英文摘要:

Total mass is arguably the most fundamental property for cosmological studies with galaxy clusters. We investigate the present differences in the mass estimates obtained through independent X-ray, weak-lensing, and dynamical studies. We quantify the differences as the mean ratio 1-$b$=M$_{\rm HE}$/M$_{\rm WL,dyn}$, where HE refers to hydrostatic masses obtained from X-ray observations, WL refers to the results of weak-lensing measurements, and dyn refers to the mass estimates either from velocity dispersion or from the caustic technique. Recent X-ray masses reported by independent groups show average differences smaller than $\sim$10$\%$, posing a strong limit on the systematics that can be ascribed to the differences in the X-ray analysis when studying the hydrostatic bias. The mean ratio between our X-ray masses and the weak-lensing masses in the LC$^2$-single catalog is 1-$b$=0.74$\pm$0.06. However, the mean mass ratios inferred from the WL masses of different projects vary by a large amount, with APEX-SZ showing a bias consistent with zero (1-$b$=1.02$\pm$0.12), LoCuSS and CCCP/MENeaCS showing a significant difference (1-$b$=0.76$\pm$0.09 and 1-$b$=0.77$\pm$0.10, respectively), and WtG pointing to the largest deviation (1-$b$=0.61$\pm$0.12). At odds with the WL results, the dynamical mass measurements show better agreement with the X-ray hydrostatic masses, although there are significant differences when relaxed or disturbed clusters are used. The different ratios obtained using different mass estimators suggest that there are still systematics that are not accounted for in all the techniques used to recover cluster masses. This prevents the determination of firm constraints on the level of hydrostatic mass bias in galaxy clusters.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑