自主AI法律推理中的法律判断预测(LJP)
Legal Judgment Prediction (LJP) Amid the Advent of Autonomous AI Legal Reasoning
摘要:
法律判断预测是法学理论和实务中一个长期存在的开放性课题。预测司法事务的性质和结果是法律行业和整个社会所充分保证、热切寻求和大力追求的。产生司法负载预测的脆弱行为在实用性和准确性方面受到限制,需要进一步发展。随着时间的推移,各种预测法律案件和司法行动的方法和技术已经出现,特别是随着基于计算机的建模的出现而出现。已经尝试了各种各样的方法,包括简单的计算方法,高度复杂和复杂的统计模型。基于人工智能(AI)的方法也越来越多地被利用。在本文中,我们回顾了有关法律判断预测的文献,并创新性地提出人工智能法律推理(AILR)的出现将对LJP的执行方式及其预测准确性产生显著影响。法律判断预测特别使用人工智能法律推理的自治水平(LoA)进行检查,此外,还探讨了其他考虑因素,包括LJP概率趋势,偏见处理,演员预测,透明度,司法依赖,法律案件结果以及其他涉及总体法律司法环境的关键要素。
英文摘要:
Legal Judgment Prediction (LJP) is a longstanding and open topic in the theory and practice-of-law. Predicting the nature and outcomes of judicial matters is abundantly warranted, keenly sought, and vigorously pursued by those within the legal industry and also by society as a whole. The tenuous act of generating judicially laden predictions has been limited in utility and exactitude, requiring further advancement. Various methods and techniques to predict legal cases and judicial actions have emerged over time, especially arising via the advent of computer-based modeling. There has been a wide range of approaches attempted, including simple calculative methods to highly sophisticated and complex statistical models. Artificial Intelligence (AI) based approaches have also been increasingly utilized. In this paper, a review of the literature encompassing Legal Judgment Prediction is undertaken, along with innovatively proposing that the advent of AI Legal Reasoning (AILR) will have a pronounced impact on how LJP is performed and its predictive accuracy. Legal Judgment Prediction is particularly examined using the Levels of Autonomy (LoA) of AI Legal Reasoning, plus, other considerations are explored including LJP probabilistic tendencies, biases handling, actor predictors, transparency, judicial reliance, legal case outcomes, and other crucial elements entailing the overarching legal judicial milieu.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。