灰色连帽衫项目:大烟草,大科技,以及对学术诚信的威胁
The Grey Hoodie Project: Big Tobacco, Big Tech, and the threat on academic integrity
摘要:
由于政府机构依赖学者的专家建议来制定有关人工智能的政策,因此重要的是这些学者不存在可能影响或偏见其判断的利益冲突。我们的工作探讨了大型科技公司如何积极扭曲学术环境以满足其需求。通过比较另一个行业(大烟草)的充分研究行动与大科技公司目前的行动,我们看到两个行业采用了类似的战略。这些战略使任何一个行业都能够左右和影响学术和公共话语。我们研究学术研究的资金作为大科技用来提出一个社会责任的公共形象的工具,影响由资助的大学主办的活动和决策,影响研究问题和个人科学家的计划,并发现谁可以利用接受学者。我们展示了大科技如何影响学术界,从机构层面到个人研究人员。因此,我们认为至关重要的是,特别是对大学和其他高等教育机构来说,讨论接受大科技资助的适当性和权衡,以及应该设置哪些限制或条件。
英文摘要:
As governmental bodies rely on academics' expert advice to shape policy regarding Artificial Intelligence, it is important that these academics not have conflicts of interests that may cloud or bias their judgement. Our work explores how Big Tech can actively distort the academic landscape to suit its needs. By comparing the well-studied actions of another industry (Big Tobacco) to the current actions of Big Tech we see similar strategies employed by both industries. These strategies enable either industry to sway and influence academic and public discourse. We examine the funding of academic research as a tool used by Big Tech to put forward a socially responsible public image, influence events hosted by and decisions made by funded universities, influence the research questions and plans of individual scientists, and discover receptive academics who can be leveraged. We demonstrate how Big Tech can affect academia from the institutional level down to individual researchers. Thus, we believe that it is vital, particularly for universities and other institutions of higher learning, to discuss the appropriateness and the tradeoffs of accepting funding from Big Tech, and what limitations or conditions should be put in place.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。