arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2009.12178cs.AI
收藏

我们在基于模型的诊断中真的正确采样吗?

Do We Really Sample Right In Model-Based Diagnosis?

University of Klagenfurt(克拉根福大学)

Patrick Rodler, Fatima Elichanova

摘要:

为了具有代表性,统计样本必须以随机和无偏见的方式从人口中抽取。然而,在基于模型的诊断领域中,通常的做法是从(有偏差的)最佳优先样本进行估计。一个例子是计算出一个有缺陷的系统的几个最可能的故障解释,并使用这些来评估系统的哪个方面,如果测量,将带来最高的信息增益。在这项工作中,我们仔细检查这些统计上没有充分依据的惯例,诊断研究人员和从业者都坚持了几十年,确实是合理的。为此,我们实证分析各种采样方法,产生故障的解释。我们研究了所产生的样本的代表性,在他们的估计故障的解释,以及他们如何指导诊断决策,我们调查的样本量的影响,采样效率和有效性之间的最佳权衡,以及如何近似采样技术比较准确的。

英文摘要:

Statistical samples, in order to be representative, have to be drawn from a population in a random and unbiased way. Nevertheless, it is common practice in the field of model-based diagnosis to make estimations from (biased) best-first samples. One example is the computation of a few most probable possible fault explanations for a defective system and the use of these to assess which aspect of the system, if measured, would bring the highest information gain. In this work, we scrutinize whether these statistically not well-founded conventions, that both diagnosis researchers and practitioners have adhered to for decades, are indeed reasonable. To this end, we empirically analyze various sampling methods that generate fault explanations. We study the representativeness of the produced samples in terms of their estimations about fault explanations and how well they guide diagnostic decisions, and we investigate the impact of sample size, the optimal trade-off between sampling efficiency and effectivity, and how approximate sampling techniques compare to exact ones.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑