arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2009.10385cs.CY
收藏

缩小了AI研究的范围?

A narrowing of AI research?

Joel Klinger, Juan Mateos-Garcia, Konstantinos Stathoulopoulos

摘要:

深度学习技术能够从大型数据集中推断模式,这极大地提高了人工智能(AI)系统的性能。然而,深度学习的快速发展和采用在很大程度上是由大型科技公司领导的,尽管人工智能研究存在缺陷,包括缺乏鲁棒性、环境成本高以及潜在的技术轨迹过早缩小,但人们仍然担心人工智能研究的技术轨迹会过早缩小。不公平的结果。我们试图通过对arXiv(一个流行的预印本数据库)中AI研究的语义分析来改进证据库。我们研究了人工智能研究主题多样性的演变,比较了学术界和私营部门人工智能研究的主题多样性,并通过它们收到的引文及其与其他机构的合作来衡量私营公司在人工智能研究中的影响力。我们的研究结果表明,近年来人工智能研究的多样性停滞不前,涉及私营部门的人工智能研究往往比学术界的研究更少多样性,更有影响力。我们还发现,私营部门的人工智能研究人员倾向于专注于数据饥渴和计算密集型的深度学习方法,而牺牲了涉及其他人工智能方法的研究,考虑人工智能的社会和伦理影响的研究,以及在健康等领域的应用。我们的研究结果为政策行动提供了理论依据,以防止人工智能研究过早缩小,这可能会限制其社会效益,但我们注意到阻碍这种干预的信息,激励和规模障碍。

英文摘要:

The arrival of deep learning techniques able to infer patterns from large datasets has dramatically improved the performance of Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems. Deep learning's rapid development and adoption, in great part led by large technology companies, has however created concerns about a premature narrowing in the technological trajectory of AI research despite its weaknesses, which include lack of robustness, high environmental costs, and potentially unfair outcomes. We seek to improve the evidence base with a semantic analysis of AI research in arXiv, a popular pre-prints database. We study the evolution of the thematic diversity of AI research, compare the thematic diversity of AI research in academia and the private sector and measure the influence of private companies in AI research through the citations they receive and their collaborations with other institutions. Our results suggest that diversity in AI research has stagnated in recent years, and that AI research involving the private sector tends to be less diverse and more influential than research in academia. We also find that private sector AI researchers tend to specialise in data-hungry and computationally intensive deep learning methods at the expense of research involving other AI methods, research that considers the societal and ethical implications of AI, and applications in sectors like health. Our results provide a rationale for policy action to prevent a premature narrowing of AI research that could constrain its societal benefits, but we note the informational, incentive and scale hurdles standing in the way of such interventions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑