arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2008.10712physics.ed-ph
收藏

物理学GRE并不能帮助申请人“脱颖而出”

The Physics GRE does not help applicants "stand out"

Nicholas T. Young, Marcos D. Caballero

摘要:

保留物理GRE的一个理由是,它可以帮助那些在录取过程中可能被错过的申请人脱颖而出。在这项工作中,我们评估这种说法是否支持物理研究生院的招生决定。我们使用了5个授予博士学位的物理系在2年内(N=2537)的招生数据,以了解申请人的录取比例如何根据他们的物理GRE成绩而变化。我们比较了GPA较低的申请人与GPA较高的申请人,大型本科大学的申请人与小型本科大学的申请人,以及选择性本科院校的申请人与选择性较低的本科院校的申请人。我们还进行了调解和适度分析,以提供统计上的严谨性,并更好地理解以前的关系。我们发现,对于那些可能被错过的申请人(例如,GPA低或参加了一个小的或不太有选择性的学校),具有高物理GRE成绩似乎并没有增加申请人被录取的机会。然而,物理GRE成绩低似乎会使其他竞争对手的申请者受到惩罚。因此,我们的研究表明,物理GRE实际上并没有帮助那些可能被错过的申请人脱颖而出。

英文摘要:

One argument for keeping the physics GRE is that it can help applicants who might otherwise be missed in the admissions process stand out. In this work, we evaluate whether this claim is supported by physics graduate school admissions decisions. We used admissions data from five PhD-granting physics departments over a 2-year period (N=2537) to see how the fraction of applicants admitted varied based on their physics GRE scores. We compared applicants with low GPAs to applicants with higher GPAs, applicants from large undergraduate universities to applicants from smaller undergraduate universities, and applicants from selective undergraduate institutions to applicants from less selective undergraduate institutions. We also performed a mediation and moderation analysis to provide statistical rigor and to better understand the previous relationships. We find that for applicants who might otherwise have been missed (e.g. have a low GPA or attended a small or less selective school) having a high physics GRE score did not seem to increase the applicant's chances of being admitted to the schools. However, having a low physics GRE score seemed to penalize otherwise competitive applicants. Thus, our work suggests that the physics GRE does not, in fact, help applicants who might otherwise be missed stand out.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑