arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2008.06913cs.CR
收藏

SoK:为什么Johnny不能解决PGP标准化问题

SoK: Why Johnny Can't Fix PGP Standardization

Harry Halpin

摘要:

PGP(Pretty Good Privacy)长期以来一直是IETF加密电子邮件的主要标准,但普遍存在的可用性和安全问题限制了其采用。随着时间的推移,底层的加密协议已经过时,因为PGP是基于每条消息的未经身份验证的,并且在加密之前进行压缩。PGP生态系统使用的越来越过时的原语和复杂的客户端受到越来越多的攻击。然而,除了添加现代加密原语之外,在IETF更新OpenPGP标准的尝试都失败了。在官方标准化之外,Autocrypt是一个“自下而上”的社区尝试来修复PGP,但仍然成为涉及身份验证的PGP攻击的受害者。无法“修复”PGP的核心原因是缺乏一个简单的AEAD接口,这反过来又需要一个分散的公钥基础设施来处理电子邮件。然而,即使像MLS这样的标准取代了PGP,分散式PKI的部署仍然是一个悬而未决的问题。

英文摘要:

Pretty Good Privacy (PGP) has long been the primary IETF standard for encrypting email, but suffers from widespread usability and security problems that have limited its adoption. As time has marched on, the underlying cryptographic protocol has fallen out of date insofar as PGP is unauthenticated on a per message basis and compresses before encryption. There have been an increasing number of attacks on the increasingly outdated primitives and complex clients used by the PGP eco-system. However, attempts to update the OpenPGP standard have failed at the IETF except for adding modern cryptographic primitives. Outside of official standardization, Autocrypt is a "bottom-up" community attempt to fix PGP, but still falls victim to attacks on PGP involving authentication. The core reason for the inability to "fix" PGP is the lack of a simple AEAD interface which in turn requires a decentralized public key infrastructure to work with email. Yet even if standards like MLS replace PGP, the deployment of a decentralized PKI remains an open issue.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑