刻画在线破坏行为:理性选择视角
Characterizing Online Vandalism: A Rational Choice Perspective
AI总结:
本文结合理性选择理论与价值期望理论,对 Wikipedia 的141个破坏实例进行混合方法分析,提出在线内容社区破坏行为本体,并揭示可识别性、政策历史和破坏成本对行为特征的影响。
摘要:
哪些因素会影响实施破坏的决定?尽管其危害显而易见,但破坏者获得的收益却不那么明确。在许多情况下,被破坏的对象本身可能正是破坏者使用或喜爱的事物。破坏行为具有传播价值:这种价值或许面向破坏者自身,或许面向破坏行为所针对的某些受众,也或许面向普通公众。尽管破坏者具有反规范行为,但仍将其视为理性的社区参与者,这为以新颖方式介入或反制他们的选择提供了可能。应用于价值期望理论(VET)中的理性选择理论(RCT),提供了一种在理性选择框架内刻画行为的策略;该理论始于这样一种假设:在个人偏好与约束受到某种加权的条件下,个体会通过实施破坏行为来最大化自身效用。本研究应用 RCT 与 VET 框架,以深入理解破坏者的偏好和约束。通过对 Wikipedia 进行混合方法分析,我结合社会计算与犯罪学关于破坏行为的视角,为在线内容社区提出了一种破坏行为本体。我使用该本体对 141 个破坏实例进行分类,并发现破坏行为的特征会随破坏者的相对可识别性、其在 Wikipedia 上的政策历史以及实施破坏所需的努力而变化。
英文摘要:
What factors influence the decision to vandalize? Although the harm is clear, the benefit to the vandal is less clear. In many cases, the thing being damaged may itself be something the vandal uses or enjoys. Vandalism holds communicative value: perhaps to the vandal themselves, to some audience at whom the vandalism is aimed, and to the general public. Viewing vandals as rational community participants despite their antinormative behavior offers the possibility of engaging with or countering their choices in novel ways. Rational choice theory (RCT) as applied in value expectancy theory (VET) offers a strategy for characterizing behaviors in a framework of rational choices, and begins with the supposition that subject to some weighting of personal preferences and constraints, individuals maximize their own utility by committing acts of vandalism. This study applies the framework of RCT and VET to gain insight into vandals' preferences and constraints. Using a mixed-methods analysis of Wikipedia, I combine social computing and criminological perspectives on vandalism to propose an ontology of vandalism for online content communities. I use this ontology to categorize 141 instances of vandalism and find that the character of vandalistic acts varies by vandals' relative identifiability, policy history with Wikipedia, and the effort required to vandalize.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。