arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2006.16453math.HOcs.LO
收藏

弗雷格的类型论

Frege's theory of types

Bruno Bentzen

AI总结:

本文提出将弗雷格《算术基础法则》中的一阶函数名称解释为简单类型论中的开放项,而非封闭函数项,以更忠实地近似其层级理论,并扩展至二阶函数。

摘要:

人们常说,弗雷格在《算术基础法则》中提出的函数层级理论预示了支撑丘奇简单类型论的层级类型结构。这一说法大致认为,在《算术基础法则》的阐述语言中,弗雷格预设了简单类型论意义上的函数类型。然而,这种观点难以容纳二元函数名称,并将函数视为不完整实体。我提出并捍卫一种对《算术基础法则》中一阶函数名称的替代解释,即将它们解释为简单类型论中的开放项,而非函数类型的封闭项。这种解释提供了一种虽仍非历史性的、但更为忠实的对弗雷格层级理论的类型论近似,并且可以自然地扩展以容纳二阶函数。这一解释之所以可能,基于两个关键观察:弗雷格的罗马标记本质上类似于开放项,且弗雷格缺乏区分罗马标记与函数名称的明确标准。

英文摘要:

It is often claimed that the theory of function levels proposed by Frege in Grundgesetze der Arithmetik anticipates the hierarchy of types that underlies Church's simple theory of types. This claim roughly states that Frege presupposes a type of functions in the sense of simple type theory in the expository language of Grundgesetze. However, this view makes it hard to accommodate function names of two arguments and view functions as incomplete entities. I propose and defend an alternative interpretation of first-level function names in Grundgesetze into simple type-theoretic open terms rather than into closed terms of a function type. This interpretation offers a still unhistorical but more faithful type-theoretic approximation of Frege's theory of levels and can be naturally extended to accommodate second-level functions. It is made possible by two key observations that Frege's Roman markers behave essentially like open terms and that Frege lacks a clear criterion for distinguishing between Roman markers and function names.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑