We investigate the Plackett-Luce (PL) model based listwise learning-to-rank (LTR) on data with partitioned preference, where a set of items are sliced into ordered and disjoint partitions, but the ranking of items within a partition is unknown. Given $N$ items with $M$ partitions, calculating the likelihood of data with partitioned preference under the PL model has a time complexity of $O(N+S!)$, where $S$ is the maximum size of the top $M-1$ partitions. This computational challenge restrains most existing PL-based listwise LTR methods to a special case of partitioned preference, top-$K$ ranking, where the exact order of the top $K$ items is known. In this paper, we exploit a random utility model formulation of the PL model, and propose an efficient numerical integration approach for calculating the likelihood and its gradients with a time complexity $O(N+S^3)$. We demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms well-known LTR baselines and remains scalable through both simulation experiments and applications to real-world eXtreme Multi-Label classification tasks.
University of Technology Sydney（悉尼科技大学）；RIKEN（日本理化学研究所）
The aggregation of k-ary preferences is a historical and important problem, since it has many real-world applications, such as peer grading, presidential elections and restaurant ranking. Meanwhile, variants of Plackett-Luce model has been applied to aggregate k-ary preferences. However, there are two urgent issues still existing in the current variants. First, most of them ignore feature information. Namely, they consider k-ary preferences instead of instance-dependent k-ary preferences. Second, these variants barely consider the uncertainty in k-ary preferences provided by agnostic crowds. I…
Mixtures of ranking models have been widely used for heterogeneous preferences. However, learning a mixture model is highly nontrivial, especially when the dataset consists of partial orders. In such cases, the parameter of the model may not be even identifiable. In this paper, we focus on three popular structures of partial orders: ranked top-$l_1$, $l_2$-way, and choice data over a subset of alternatives. We prove that when the dataset consists of combinations of ranked top-$l_1$ and $l_2$-way (or choice data over up to $l_2$ alternatives), mixture of $k$ Plackett-Luce models is not identifi…
National Research University Higher School of Economics（国立研究型大学高等经济学院）；University of Sussex（萨塞克斯大学）
Learning models with discrete latent variables using stochastic gradient descent remains a challenge due to the high variance of gradient estimates. Modern variance reduction techniques mostly consider categorical distributions and have limited applicability when the number of possible outcomes becomes large. In this work, we consider models with latent permutations and propose control variates for the Plackett-Luce distribution. In particular, the control variates allow us to optimize black-box functions over permutations using stochastic gradient descent. To illustrate the approach, we consi…
We consider PAC-learning a good item from $k$-subsetwise feedback information sampled from a Plackett-Luce probability model, with instance-dependent sample complexity performance. In the setting where subsets of a fixed size can be tested and top-ranked feedback is made available to the learner, we give an algorithm with optimal instance-dependent sample complexity, for PAC best arm identification, of $O\bigg(\frac{θ_{[k]}}{k}\sum_{i = 2}^n\max\Big(1,\frac{1}{Δ_i^2}\Big) \ln\frac{k}δ\Big(\ln \frac{1}{Δ_i}\Big)\bigg)$, $Δ_i$ being the Plackett-Luce parameter gap between the best and the $i^{th…
In this paper we address the identifiability and efficient learning problems of finite mixtures of Plackett-Luce models for rank data. We prove that for any $k\geq 2$, the mixture of $k$ Plackett-Luce models for no more than $2k-1$ alternatives is non-identifiable and this bound is tight for $k=2$. For generic identifiability, we prove that the mixture of $k$ Plackett-Luce models over $m$ alternatives is generically identifiable if $k\leq\lfloor\frac {m-2} 2\rfloor!$. We also propose an efficient generalized method of moments (GMM) algorithm to learn the mixture of two Plackett-Luce models and…
Mixture models of Plackett-Luce (PL) -- one of the most fundamental ranking models -- are an active research area of both theoretical and practical significance. Most previously proposed parameter estimation algorithms instantiate the EM algorithm, often with random initialization. However, such an initialization scheme may not yield a good initial estimate and the algorithms require multiple restarts, incurring a large time complexity. As for the EM procedure, while the E-step can be performed efficiently, maximizing the log-likelihood in the M-step is difficult due to the combinatorial natur…
List-wise based learning to rank methods are generally supposed to have better performance than point- and pair-wise based. However, in real-world applications, state-of-the-art systems are not from list-wise based camp. In this paper, we propose a new non-linear algorithm in the list-wise based framework called ListMLE, which uses the Plackett-Luce (PL) loss. Our experiments are conducted on the two largest publicly available real-world datasets, Yahoo challenge 2010 and Microsoft 30K. This is the first time in the single model level for a list-wise based system to match or overpass state-of-…
Heinz Nixdorf Institute（海因茨·尼多夫研究所）；Department of Computer Science（计算机科学系）；Paderborn University（帕德博恩大学）；Germany（德国（注：此处原文本中“Germany”为国家名，根据提取规则，机构粒度为大学/学院/公司/研究院级别，“Germany”并非机构，不应提取。但根据用户提供的HTML开头文本，原Affiliation部分包含“Paderborn University, Germany”，其中“Paderborn University”是机构，“Germany”是国家，属于额外信息，应忽略。同时，“Heinz Nixdorf Institute and Department of Computer Science”中的“Heinz Nixdorf Institute”是机构，“Department of Computer Science”属于系/部门，不应提取。但用户提供的示例中，可能存在对“Department of Computer Science”是否提取的疑问，根据用户的提取规则“不要细拆到系、专业、课题组、实验室”，因此“Department of Computer Science”不应提取。正确的机构应为：）{）
We consider an extension of the contextual multi-armed bandit problem, in which, instead of selecting a single alternative (arm), a learner is supposed to make a preselection in the form of a subset of alternatives. More specifically, in each iteration, the learner is presented a set of arms and a context, both described in terms of feature vectors. The task of the learner is to preselect $k$ of these arms, among which a final choice is made in a second step. In our setup, we assume that each arm has a latent (context-dependent) utility, and that feedback on a preselection is produced accordin…
Plackett-Luce gradient estimation enables the optimization of stochastic ranking models within feasible time constraints through sampling techniques. Unfortunately, the computational complexity of existing methods does not scale well with the length of the rankings, i.e. the ranking cutoff, nor with the item collection size. In this paper, we introduce the novel PL-Rank-3 algorithm that performs unbiased gradient estimation with a computational complexity comparable to the best sorting algorithms. As a result, our novel learning-to-rank method is applicable in any scenario where standard sorti…
The Plackett-Luce (PL) model is ubiquitous in learning-to-rank (LTR) because it provides a useful and intuitive probabilistic model for sampling ranked lists. Counterfactual offline evaluation and optimization of ranking metrics are pivotal for using LTR methods in production. When adopting the PL model as a ranking policy, both tasks require the computation of expectations with respect to the model. These are usually approximated via Monte-Carlo (MC) sampling, since the combinatorial scaling in the number of items to be ranked makes their analytical computation intractable. Despite recent adv…
We introduce the probably approximately correct (PAC) \emph{Battling-Bandit} problem with the Plackett-Luce (PL) subset choice model--an online learning framework where at each trial the learner chooses a subset of $k$ arms from a fixed set of $n$ arms, and subsequently observes a stochastic feedback indicating preference information of the items in the chosen subset, e.g., the most preferred item or ranking of the top $m$ most preferred items etc. The objective is to identify a near-best item in the underlying PL model with high confidence. This generalizes the well-studied PAC \emph{Dueling-…
We propose a novel and flexible rank-breaking-then-composite-marginal-likelihood (RBCML) framework for learning random utility models (RUMs), which include the Plackett-Luce model. We characterize conditions for the objective function of RBCML to be strictly log-concave by proving that strict log-concavity is preserved under convolution and marginalization. We characterize necessary and sufficient conditions for RBCML to satisfy consistency and asymptotic normality. Experiments on synthetic data show that RBCML for Gaussian RUMs achieves better statistical efficiency and computational efficien…
Paderborn University（帕德博恩大学）；University of Munich (LMU)（慕尼黑大学（LMU））；L3S Research Center（L3S研究中心）；Leibniz University Hannover（汉诺威莱布尼茨大学）；TIB Hannover（汉诺威技术信息图书馆）
In many real-world applications, the relative depth of objects in an image is crucial for scene understanding. Recent approaches mainly tackle the problem of depth prediction in monocular images by treating the problem as a regression task. Yet, being interested in an order relation in the first place, ranking methods suggest themselves as a natural alternative to regression, and indeed, ranking approaches leveraging pairwise comparisons as training information ("object A is closer to the camera than B") have shown promising performance on this problem. In this paper, we elaborate on the use o…
Optimizing Group-Fair Plackett-Luce Ranking Models for Relevance and Ex-Post Fairness
Indian Institute of Science（印度科学研究所）；University of California, Berkeley（加利福尼亚大学伯克利分校）；Microsoft Research, Bengaluru（微软研究院班加罗尔分院）；Microsoft Research（微软研究院）
Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India（印度科学学院，班加罗尔，印度）
We consider the problem of probably approximately correct (PAC) ranking $n$ items by adaptively eliciting subset-wise preference feedback. At each round, the learner chooses a subset of $k$ items and observes stochastic feedback indicating preference information of the winner (most preferred) item of the chosen subset drawn according to a Plackett-Luce (PL) subset choice model unknown a priori. The objective is to identify an $ε$-optimal ranking of the $n$ items with probability at least $1 - δ$. When the feedback in each subset round is a single Plackett-Luce-sampled item, we show $(ε, δ)$-PA…
Ohio State University（俄亥俄州立大学）；Iowa State University（爱荷华州立大学）
This paper explores the adaptive (active) PAC (probably approximately correct) top-$k$ ranking (i.e., top-$k$ item selection) and total ranking problems from $l$-wise ($l\geq 2$) comparisons under the multinomial logit (MNL) model. By adaptively choosing sets to query and observing the noisy output of the most favored item of each query, we want to design ranking algorithms that recover the top-$k$ or total ranking using as few queries as possible. For the PAC top-$k$ ranking problem, we derive a lower bound on the sample complexity (aka number of queries), and propose an algorithm that is sam…
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute（伦斯勒理工学院）；College of William and Mary（威廉与玛丽学院）
This paper studies a stylized, yet natural, learning-to-rank problem and points out the critical incorrectness of a widely used nearest neighbor algorithm. We consider a model with $n$ agents (users) $\{x_i\}_{i \in [n]}$ and $m$ alternatives (items) $\{y_j\}_{j \in [m]}$, each of which is associated with a latent feature vector. Agents rank items nondeterministically according to the Plackett-Luce model, where the higher the utility of an item to the agent, the more likely this item will be ranked high by the agent. Our goal is to find neighbors of an arbitrary agent or alternative in the lat…
In this paper, we propose new listwise learning-to-rank models that mitigate the shortcomings of existing ones. Existing listwise learning-to-rank models are generally derived from the classical Plackett-Luce model, which has three major limitations. (1) Its permutation probabilities overlook ties, i.e., a situation when more than one document has the same rating with respect to a query. This can lead to imprecise permutation probabilities and inefficient training because of selecting documents one by one. (2) It does not favor documents having high relevance. (3) It has a loose assumption tha…
Fast and Robust Rank Aggregation against Model Misspecification
Center for Frontier AI Research（前沿人工智能研究中心）；Agency for Science, Technology and Research (A*STAR)（新加坡科技研究局）；Australian Artificial Intelligence Institute（澳大利亚人工智能研究所）；University of Technology Sydney（悉尼科技大学）；Zhijiang College（之江学院）；Zhejiang University of Technology（浙江工业大学）；Center for Advanced Intelligence Project（高级智能项目中心）；RIKEN（理化学研究所）；Graduate School of Frontier Sciences（前沿科学研究生院）；University of Tokyo（东京大学）
Indian Institute of Technology, Madras（印度理工学院马德拉斯分校）
We study the problem of rank aggregation where the goal is to obtain a global ranking by aggregating pair-wise comparisons of voters over a set of items. We consider an adversarial setting where the voters are partitioned into two sets. The first set votes in a stochastic manner according to the popular score-based Bradley-Terry-Luce (BTL) model for pairwise comparisons. The second set comprises malicious Byzantine voters trying to deteriorate the ranking. We consider a strongly-adversarial scenario where the Byzantine voters know the BTL scores, the votes of the good voters, the algorithm, an…
