给我方便,给她死亡:谁应该决定什么用途的NLP是适当的,在什么基础上?
Give Me Convenience and Give Her Death: Who Should Decide What Uses of NLP are Appropriate, and on What Basis?
摘要:
随着NLP能力的不断增强,加上人们对研究伦理层面的认识,人们提出了一些问题,即特定的数据集和任务是否应该被视为NLP研究的禁区。我们针对EMNLP 2019中关于自动法律判决的论文研究了这个问题,该论文引起了一些争论,询问是否应该允许发表该论文,谁应该被指控做出这样的决定,以及基于什么。我们特别关注数据声明在伦理评估研究中的作用,但也讨论了双重用途的话题,并研究了其他科学学科中类似辩论的结果。
英文摘要:
As part of growing NLP capabilities, coupled with an awareness of the ethical dimensions of research, questions have been raised about whether particular datasets and tasks should be deemed off-limits for NLP research. We examine this question with respect to a paper on automatic legal sentencing from EMNLP 2019 which was a source of some debate, in asking whether the paper should have been allowed to be published, who should have been charged with making such a decision, and on what basis. We focus in particular on the role of data statements in ethically assessing research, but also discuss the topic of dual use, and examine the outcomes of similar debates in other scientific disciplines.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。