arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2005.10314econ.EM
收藏

论回归分析中控制变量的干扰性

On the Nuisance of Control Variables in Regression Analysis

Paul Hünermund, Beyers Louw

AI总结:

本文指出回归分析中控制变量的估计效应通常缺乏因果解释,建议避免解释其边际效应,并明确标记或省略其系数,以防误导管理或政策决策及后续理论构建。

摘要:

在回归分析中纳入控制变量是为了估计处理对结果的因果效应。然而,本文认为控制变量的估计效应大小本身不太可能具有因果解释。这是因为即使有效的控制变量也可能是内生的,并代表共同作用于结果的几种不同因果机制的组合,这在理论上很难解释。因此,我们建议避免解释控制变量的边际效应,而应将重点放在能够建立合理识别论证的主要感兴趣变量上。为防止得出错误的管理或政策启示,控制变量的系数应明确标记为不具有因果解释,或直接从回归表中省略。此外,我们建议不要将控制变量的估计值用于后续的理论构建和元分析。

英文摘要:

Control variables are included in regression analyses to estimate the causal effect of a treatment on an outcome. In this paper, we argue that the estimated effect sizes of controls are unlikely to have a causal interpretation themselves, though. This is because even valid controls are possibly endogenous and represent a combination of several different causal mechanisms operating jointly on the outcome, which is hard to interpret theoretically. Therefore, we recommend refraining from interpreting marginal effects of controls and focusing on the main variables of interest, for which a plausible identification argument can be established. To prevent erroneous managerial or policy implications, coefficients of control variables should be clearly marked as not having a causal interpretation or omitted from regression tables altogether. Moreover, we advise against using control variable estimates for subsequent theory building and meta-analyses.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑