对COVID-19的一些近期工作的批判性评价
A Critical Assessment of Some Recent Work on COVID-19
摘要:
我尝试性地重新分析了两项广为宣传的COVID-19研究的数据,即Charité的“儿童病毒载量”和Bonn的“Heinsberg/Gangelt血清阳性率”研究,这些数据来自预印本中的信息。这些研究有以下共同点:-它们受到全世界的关注,可以说具有政策影响。- 他们的研究结果的主旨与各自主要作者在适当应对COVID-19方面的(不同)公开立场一致。- 然而,我对冈格尔特研究的解读抵消了它的推力,而对查里特研究的解读则相反,这一练习可能有助于将这些研究纳入文献。基于预印本,所有适用于n=2速射分析的警告,人们也想知道它是否说明了“研究人员自由度"的无意影响。"
英文摘要:
I tentatively re-analyze data from two well-publicized studies on COVID-19, namely the Charité "viral load in children" and the Bonn "seroprevalence in Heinsberg/Gangelt" study, from information available in the preprints. The studies have the following in common: - They received worldwide attention and arguably had policy impact. - The thrusts of their findings align with the respective lead authors' (different) public stances on appropriate response to COVID-19. - Tentatively, my reading of the Gangelt study neutralizes its thrust, and my reading of the Charité study reverses it. The exercise may aid in placing these studies in the literature. With all caveats that apply to n=2 quickfire analyses based off preprints, one also wonders whether it illustrates inadvertent effects of "researcher degrees of freedom."
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。